Emakimono (絵巻物, emaki-mono, literally 'picture scroll') or emaki (絵巻) are Japanese illustrated handscrolls that have been produced since the 10th century. Emakimono combine both text and image in telling a narrative, and reveal chronological sections of a story as the readers unrolls the scroll from right to left.
Emakimono depict a variety of stories including battles, romance, religion, folk tales, and stories of the supernatural world. They are intended to provide cultural information and teach moral values.
|National Treasures and Important Cultural Properties of National Institutes for Cultural Heritage, Japan: browse the entire seventh scroll of the Ippen Shonin Eden|
|Museum of Fine Arts, Boston: browse the first scroll of the Heiji Monogatari Emaki|
|Metropolitan Museum of Art: viewing a Japanese handscroll|
The term emakimono or e-makimono, often abbreviated as emaki, is made up of the kanji e (絵, "painting"), maki (巻, "scroll" or "book") and mono (物, "thing"). The term refers to long scrolls of painted paper or silk, which range in length from under a metre to several metres long. These scrolls tell a story or a succession of anecdotes (such as literary chronicles or Buddhist parables), combining pictorial and narrative elements, the combination of which characterises the dominant art movements in Japan between the 12th and 14th centuries.
An emakimono is read, according to the traditional method, sitting on a mat with the scroll placed on a low table or on the floor. The reader then unwinds with one hand while rewinding it with the other hand, from right to left (according to the writing direction of Japanese). In this way, only part of the story can be seen – about 60 centimetres (24 in), though more can be unrolled – and the artist creates a succession of images to construct the story.
Once the emakimono has been read, the reader must rewind the scroll again in its original reading direction. The emakimono is kept closed by a cord and stored alone or with other rolls in a box intended for this purpose, and which is sometimes decorated with elaborate patterns. An emakimono can consist of several successive scrolls as required of the story - the Hōnen Shonin Eden was made up of 48 scrolls, although the standard number typically falls between one and three.
An emakimono is made up of two elements: the sections of calligraphic text known as kotoba-gaki, and the sections of paintings referred to as e; their size, arrangement and number vary greatly, depending on the period and the artist. In emakimono inspired by literature, the text occupies no less than two-thirds of the space, while other more popular works, such as the Chōjū-jinbutsu-giga, favour the image, sometimes to the point of making the text disappear. The scrolls have a limited height (on average between 30 cm (12 in) and 39 cm (15 in)), compared with their length (on average 9 m (30 ft) to 12 m (39 ft)), meaning that emakimono are therefore limited to being read alone, historically by the aristocracy and members of the high clergy.
Example of a complete scroll of an emakimono, the Ippen Shonin Eden (seventh scroll, 1299, Tokyo National Museum). Reading direction is from right to left. Traditionally, the reader never fully unwinds the roll, but unwinds it with one hand while rewinding it with the other, learning the story piecemeal.
Handscrolls are believed to have been invented in India before the fourth century BCE. They were used for religious texts and entered China by the first century CE. Handscrolls were introduced to Japan centuries later through the spread of Buddhism. The earliest extant Japanese handscroll was created in the eighth century CE and focuses on the life of the Buddha.
The origins of Japanese handscrolls can be found in China and, to a lesser extent, in Korea, the main sources of Japanese artistic inspiration until modern times. Narrative art forms in China can be traced back to between the third century BCE under the Han dynasty and the second century CE under the Zhou dynasty, the pottery of which was adorned with hunting scenes juxtaposed with movements. Paper was invented in China in about the first century CE, simplifying the writing on scrolls of laws or sutra, sometimes decorated. The first narrative scrolls arrived later; various masters showed interest in this medium, including Gu Kaizhi (345-406), who experimented with new techniques. Genre painting and Chinese characters, dominant in the scrolls up to the tenth century CE, remain little known to this day, because they were overshadowed by the famous landscape scrolls of the Song dynasty.
Relations with East Asia (mainly China and Korea) brought Chinese writing (Kanji) to Japan by the fourth century, and Buddhism in the sixth century, together with interest in the apparently very effective bureaucracy of the mighty Chinese Empire. In the Nara period, the Japanese were inspired by the Tang dynasty: administration, architecture, dress customs or ceremonies. The exchanges between China and Japan were also fruitful for the arts, mainly religious arts, and the artists of the Japanese archipelago were eager to copy and appropriate continental techniques. In that context, experts assume that the first Chinese painted scrolls arrived on the islands around the sixth century CE, and probably correspond to illustrated sutra. Thus, the oldest known Japanese narrative painted scroll (or emakimono) dates from the seventh century to the Nara period: the Illustrated Sutra of Cause and Effect, which traces the life of the Gautama Buddha, founder of the Buddhist religion, until his Illumination. Still naive in style (Six Dynasties and early Tang dynasty) with the paintings arranged in friezes above the text, it is very likely a copy of an older Chinese model, several versions of which have been identified. Although subsequent classical emakimono feature a very different style from that of this work, it foreshadows the golden age of the movement that came four centuries later, from the twelfth century CE onwards.
Heian period: genesis of the art
Arts and literature, birth of a national aesthetic
The Heian period appears today as a peak of Japanese civilization via the culture of the emperor's court, although intrigue and disinterest in things of the state resulted in the Genpei War. That perception arises from the aesthetics and the codified and refined art of living that developed at the Heian court, as well as a certain restraint and melancholy born from the feeling of the impermanence of things (a state of mind referred to as mono no aware in Japanese). Furthermore, the rupture of relations with China until the ninth century, due to disorders related to the collapse of the glorious Tang dynasty, promoted what Miyeko Murase has described as the "emergence of national taste" as a truly Japanese culture departed for the first time from Chinese influence since the early Kofun period. That development was first observed in the literature of the Heian women: unlike the men, who studied Chinese writing (kanji) from a young age, the women adopted a new syllabary, the kana, which was simpler and more consistent with the phonetics of Japanese. Heian period novels (monogatari) and diaries (nikki) recorded intimate details about life, love affairs and intrigues at court as they developed; the best known of these is the radical Tale of Genji by Murasaki Shikibu, courtesan of the tenth century.
The beginnings of the Japanese-inspired Heian period painting technique, retrospectively named yamato-e, can be found initially in some aspects of Buddhist painting of the new esoteric Tendai and Shingon sects, then more strongly in Pure Land Buddhism (Jodō): after a phase when Chinese techniques were copied, the art of the Japanese archipelago became progressively more delicate, lyrical, decorative with less powerful but more colorful compositions. Nevertheless, it was especially in secular art that the nascent yamato-e was felt most strongly; its origins went back to the sliding partitions and screens of the Heian Imperial Palace, covered with paintings on paper or silk, the themes of which were chosen from waka court poetry, annual rites, seasons or the famous lives and landscapes of the archipelago (meisho-e).
This secular art then spread among the nobles, especially the ladies interested in the illustration of novels, and seems to have become prevalent early in the tenth century. As with religious painting, the themes of Japanese life, appreciated by the nobles, did not fit well with painting of Chinese sensibility, so much so that court artists developed to a certain extent a new national technique which appeared to be fashionable in the eleventh century, for example in the seasonal landscapes of the panel paintings in the Phoenix Hall (鳳凰堂, Hōō-dō) or Amida Hall at the Byōdō-in temple, a masterpiece of primitive yamato-e of the early eleventh century.
Experts believe that yamato-e illustrations of novels and painted narrative scrolls, or emakimono, developed in the vein of this secular art, linked to literature and poetry. The painting technique lent itself fully to the artistic tastes of the court in the 11th century, inclined to an emotional, melancholic and refined representation of relations within the palace, and formed a pictorial vector very suited to the narrative. Even though they are mentioned in the antique texts, no emakimono of the early Heian period (ninth and tenth centuries) remains extant today; the oldest emakimono illustrating a novel mentioned in period sources is that of the Yamato Monogatari, offered to the Empress between 872 and 907.
However, the stylistic mastery of later works (from the twelfth century) leads most experts to believe that the "classical" art of emakimono grew during this period from the tenth century, first appearing in illustrations in novels or diaries produced by the ladies of the court. In addition, the initial themes remained close to waka poetry (seasons, Buddhism, nature, etc.). Therefore, the slow maturation of the movement of emakimono was closely linked to the emergence of Japanese culture and literature, as well as to the interest of courtesans soon joined by professional painters from palace workshops (e-dokoro) or temples, who created a more "professional" and successful technique. The art historians consider that the composition and painting techniques they see in the masterpieces of the late Heian period (second half of the twelfth century) were already very mature.
Fujiwara Era: classical masterpieces
If almost all emakimono belong to the genre of yamato-e, several sub-genres stand out within this style, including in the Heian period onna-e ("women's painting") and otoko-e ("men's painting"). Several classic scrolls of each genre perfectly represent these pictorial movements.
First, the Genji Monogatari Emaki (designed between around 1120 and 1140), illustrating the famous eponymous novel, narrates the political and amorous intrigues of Prince Hikaru Genji; the rich and opaque colors affixed over the entire surface of the paper (tsukuri-e method), the intimacy and melancholy of the composition and finally the illustration of the emotional peaks of the novel taking place only inside the Imperial Palace are characteristics of the onna-e subgenre of yamato-e, reserved for court narratives usually written by aristocratic ladies. In that scroll, each painting illustrates a key episode of the novel and is followed by a calligraphic extract on paper richly decorated with gold and silver powder.
The Genji Monogatari Emaki already presents the composition techniques specific to the art of emakimono: an oblique point of view, the movement of the eyes guided by long diagonals from the top right to the bottom left, and even the removal of the roofs to represent the interior of buildings (fukinuki yatai). A second notable example of the onna-e paintings in the Heian period is the Nezame Monogatari Emaki, which appears to be very similar to the Genji Monogatari Emaki, but presents softer and more decorative paintings giving pride of place to the representation of nature subtly emphasising the feelings of the characters
In contrast with court paintings inspired by women's novels (onna-e) there are other scrolls inspired by the daily life of the people, historical chronicles, the biography of famous monks, etc; ultimately, a style of emakimono depicting matters outside the palace and called otoko-e ("men's painting").
The Shigisan Engi Emaki ( middle of the twelfth century), with dynamic and free lines, light colors and a decidedly popular and humorous tone, perfectly illustrate this movement, not hesitating to depict the life of the Japanese people in its most insignificant details. Here, the color is applied only in light touches that leave the paper bare, as the supple and free line dominates the composition, unlike the constructed paintings of the court. In addition, the text occupies very limited space, the artist painting rather long scenes without fixed limits.
Two other masterpieces emerged into the light of day during the second half of the twelfth century.
First, the Chōjū-jinbutsu-giga forms a monochrome sketch in ink gently caricaturing the customs of Buddhist monks, where the spontaneity of touch stands out. Secondly, the Ban Dainagon Ekotoba tells of a political conspiracy in the year 866 by offering a surprising mixture of the two genres onna-e and otoko-e, with free lines and sometimes light, sometimes rich and opaque colors; this meeting of genres foreshadows the style that dominated a few decades later, during the Kamakura period.
While the authority of the court rapidly declined, the end of the Heian period (in 1185) was marked by the advent of the provincial lords (in particular, the Taira and the Minamoto), who acquired great power at the top of State. Exploiting the unrest associated with the Genpei War, which provided fertile ground for religious proselytism, the six realms (or destinies) Buddhist paintings (rokudō-e) – such as the Hell Scroll or the two versions of the Gaki Zōshi, otoko-e paintings – aimed to frighten the faithful with horror scenes.
Retracing the evolution of emaki remains difficult, due to the few works that have come down to us. However, the obvious mastery of the classical scrolls of the end of the Heian period testifies to at least a century of maturation and pictorial research. These foundations permitted the emakimono artists of the ensuing Kamakura period to engage in sustained production in all of the themes.
Kamakura period: the golden age of emakimono
The era covering the end of the Heian period and much of the Kamakura period, or the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, is commonly described by art historians as "the golden age" of the art of emakimono. Under the impetus of the new warrior class in power, and the new Buddhist sects, production was indeed very sustained and the themes and techniques more varied than before.
The emakimono style of the time was characterized by two aspects: the synthesis of the genres of yamato-e, and realism. Initially, the evolution marked previously by the Ban Dainagon Ekotoba (very late Heian era) was spreading very widely due to the importance given both to the freedom of brush strokes and the lightness of the tones (otoko-e), as well as bright colors rendered by thick pigments for certain elements of the scenes (onna-e). However, the very refined appearance of the court paintings later gave way to more dynamic and popular works, at least in relation to the theme, in the manner of the Shigisan Engi Emaki. For example, the Kitano Tenjin Engi Emaki recounts the life and death of Sugawara no Michizane, Minister in the ninth century and tragic figure in Japanese history, revered in the manner of a god (kami). The rich colours, the tense contours, the search for movement and the very realistic details of the faces well illustrate this mixture of styles, especially as the paintings drew their inspiration from both Buddhism and Shinto.
The realistic trends that were in vogue in Kamakura art, perfectly embodied by sculpture, were exposed in the majority of the Kamakura emakimono; indeed, the bakufu shogunate system held power over Japan, and the refined and codified art of the court gave way to more fluidity and dynamism. The greater simplicity advocated in the arts led to a more realistic and human representation (anger, pain or size). If the activity related to religion was prolific, then so too were the orders of the bushi (noble warriors). Several emakimono of historical or military chronicles are among the most famous, notably the Hōgen Monogatari Emaki (no longer extant) and the Heiji Monogatari Emaki; of the latter, the scroll kept at the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston remains highly regarded for its mastery of composition (which reaches a crescendo at the dramatic climax of the scroll, i.e. the burning of the palace and the bloody battle between foot soldiers), and for its contribution to our present day understanding of Japanese medieval weapons and armour. Akiyama Terukazu describes it as "a masterpiece on the subject of the world's military." In the same spirit, a noble warrior had the Mōko Shūrai Ekotoba designed to recount his military exploits during the Mongol invasions of Japan. Kamakura art particularly flourished in relation to realistic portraiture (nise-e); if the characters in the emakimono therefore evolved towards greater pictorial realism, some, such as the Sanjūrokkasen emaki, or the Zuijin Teiki Emaki attributed to Fujiwara no Nobuzane, directly present portrait galleries according to the iconographic techniques of the time.
A similar change was felt in religion as the esoteric Buddhist sects of the Heian era (Tendai and Shingon) gave way to Pure Land Buddhism (Jōdo), which primarily addressed the people by preaching simple practices of devotion to the Amida Buddha. These very active sects used emakimono intensively during the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries to illustrate and disseminate their doctrines.
Several religious practices influenced the Kamakura emakimono: notably, public sermons and picture explaining sessions (絵解, e-toki) led the artists to use scrolls of larger size than usual, and to represent the protagonists of the story in a somewhat disproportionate way compared with emakimono of the standard sizes, to enable those protagonists to be seen from a distance, in a typically Japanese non-realistic perspective (eg the Ippen Shonin Eden). The religious emakimono of the Kamakura period focus on the foundation of the temples, or the lives of famous monks. During that period, many of the religious institutions commissioned the workshops of painters (often monk-painters) to create emakimono recounting their foundation, or the biography of the founding monk. Among the best-known works on such themes are the illustrated biographies of Ippen, Hōnen, Shinran and Xuanzang, as well as the Kegon Engi Emaki and the Taima Mandara Engi Emaki.
The Ippen biography, painted by a monk, remains remarkable for its influences, so far rare, from the Song dynasty (via the wash technique) and the Tang dynasty (the shan shui style), as well as by its very precise representations of forts in many Japanese landscapes. As for the Saigyō Monogatari Emaki , it addresses the declining aristocracy in idealising the figure of the monk aesthete Saigyō by the beauty of its landscapes and its calligraphic poetry.
Towards the middle of the Kamakura period, there was a revival of interest in the Heian court, which already appeared to be a peak of Japanese civilization, and its refined culture. Thus the Murasaki Shikibu Diary Emaki, which traces the life and intrigues of Murasaki Shikibu, author of the The Tale of Genji (tenth century) largely reflects the painting techniques of the time, notably the tsukuri-e, but in a more decorative and extroverted style. Other works followed that trend, such as the The Tales of Ise Emaki, the Makura no Sōshi Emaki or the Sumiyoshi Monogatari Emaki.
Muromachi period: decline and otogi-zōshi
By the end of the Kamakura period, the art of emakimono was already losing its importance. Experts note, on the one hand, that emakimono had become less inspired, marked by an extreme aesthetic mannerism (such as the exaggerated use of gold and silver powder) with a composition more technical than creative; the tendency to multiply the scenes in a fixed style can be seen in the Hōnen Shonin Eden (the longest known emakimono, with 48 scrolls, completed in 1307), the Kasuga Gongen Genki E (1309) and the Dōjō-ji Engi Emaki (16th century). On the other hand, the innovative and more spiritual influences of Chinese Song art, deeply rooted in spirituality and Zen Buddhism, initiated the dominant artistic movement of wash (ink or monochromatic painting in water, sumi-e or suiboku-ga in Japanese) in the ensuing Muromachi period, guided by such famous artists as Tenshō Shūbun or Sesshū Tōyō.
A professional current was nevertheless maintained by the Tosa school: the only one still to claim the yamato-e, it produced many emakimono to the order of the court or the temples (this school of painters led the imperial edokoro until the 18th century). Tosa Mitsunobu notably produced several works on the foundation of temples: the Kiyomizu-dera Engi Emaki (1517), a scroll of the Ishiyama-dera Engi Emaki (1497), the Seikō-ji Engi emaki (1487) or a version of the Kitano Tenjin Engi Emaki (1503); he paid great attention to details and colours, despite a common composition. In a more general way, the illustration of novels in the classic yamato-e style (such as the many versions of the Genji Monogatari Emaki or The Tales of Ise Emaki) persisted during late medieval times.
If emakimono have therefore ceased to be the dominant artistic media in Japan since the end of the Kamakura period, it is in the illustration movement of Otogi-zōshi (otogi means "to tell stories") that emakimono developed a new popular vigour in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries (the Muromachi period); the term nara-ehon (literally, the book of illustrations of Nara) sometimes designated them in a controversial way (because they were anachronistic and combined books with scrolls), or more precisely as otogi-zōshi emaki or nara-emaki. These are small, symbolic and funny tales, intended to pass the time focusing on mythology, folklore, legends, religious beliefs or even contemporary society. This particular form of emakimono dates back to Heian times, but it was under Muromachi that it gained real popularity.
The relative popularity of otogi-zōshi seems to have stemmed from a burgeoning lack of enthusiasm for hectic or religious stories; the people had become more responsive to themes of dreams, laughter and the supernatural (a number of otogi-zōshi emaki depict all sorts of yōkai and folk creatures), as well as social caricatures and popular novels. Among the preserved examples are genre paintings such as Buncho no sasshi and Sazare-ichi or supernatural Buddhist tales such as the Tsuchigumo Sōshi or the Hyakki Yagyō Emaki.[note 1] From the point of view of art historians, the creativity of classical scrolls is felt even less in otogi-zōshi, because even though the composition is similar, the lack of harmony of colors and the overloaded appearance are detrimental; it seems that the production is often the work of amateurs. However, a field of study of nara-ehon and the nara-e pictorial style exists on the fringes and stands out from the framework of emakimono.
Various other artists, notably Tawaraya Sōtatsu and Yosa Buson, were still interested in the narrative scroll until around the 17th century. The Kanō school used narrative scrolls in the same way; Kanō Tan'yū realised several scrolls on the Tokugawa battles, particularly that of Sekigahara in his Tōshō Daigongen Engi, where he was inspired in places by the Heiji Monogatari Emaki (thirteenth century).
Features and production of emakimono
Themes and genres
In essence, an emakimono is a narrative system (like a book) that requires the construction of a story, so the composition must be based on the transitions from scene to scene until the final denouement.
Emakimono were initially strongly influenced by China, as were the Japanese arts of the time; the Illustrated Sutra of Cause and Effect incorporates many of the naive, simple styles of the Tang dynasty, although dissonances can be discerned, especially in relation to colours. From the Heian era onwards, emakimono came to be dissociated from China, mainly in their themes. Chinese scrolls were intended mainly to illustrate the transcendent principles of Buddhism and the serenity of the landscapes, suggesting the grandeur and the spirituality. The Japanese, on the other hand, had refocused their scrolls on everyday life and man, conveying drama, humour and feelings. Thus, emakimono began to be inspired by literature, poetry, nature and especially everyday life; in short, they formed an intimate art, sometimes in opposition to the search for Chinese spiritual greatness.
The first Japanese themes in the Heian period were very closely linked to waka literature and poetry: paintings of the seasons, the annual calendar of ceremonies, the countryside and finally the famous landscapes of the Japanese archipelago (meisho-e). Subsequently, the Kamakura warriors and the new Pure Land Buddhist sects diversified the subjects even more widely. Despite the wide range of emakimono themes, specialists like to categorise them, both in substance and in form. An effective method of differentiating emakimono comes back to the study of the subjects by referring to the canons of the time. The categorisation proposed by Okudaira and Fukui thus distinguishes between secular and religious paintings:
- Secular paintings
- court novels and diaries (monogatari, nikki) dealing with romantic tales, life at court or historical chronicles;
- popular legends (setsuwa monogatari);
- military accounts (kassen);
- scrolls on waka poets;
- reports on the rites and ceremonies celebrated in a very codified and rigid way throughout the year;
- realistic paintings and portraits (nise-e);
- otogi-zōshi, traditional or fantastic tales popular in the fourteenth century.
- Religious paintings
- illustrations of sutras or religious doctrines (kyu-ten);
- illustrated biography of a prominent Buddhist monk or priest (shōnin, kōsōden-e or eden);
- paintings of the antecedents of a temple (engi);
- the zōshi, a collection of Buddhist anecdotes.
A third category covers more heterogeneous works, mixing religion and narration or religion and popular humour.
The artists and their audience
|Tokyo National Museum: the Sumiyoshi Monogatari Emaki rolled up and placed in its box, colophon visible, 13th century|
|Tokyo National Museum: the start of a scroll, with the reverse side of the cover and the cord visible|
The authors of emakimono are most often unknown nowadays and it remains risky to speculate as to the names of the "masters" of emakimono. Moreover, a scroll can be the fruit of collaboration by several artists; some techniques such as tsukuri-e even naturally incline to such collaboration. Art historians are more interested in determining the social and artistic environment of painters: amateurs or professionals, at court or in temples, aristocrats or of modest birth.
In the first place, amateur painters, perhaps the initiators of the classical emakimono, are to be found at the emperor's court in Heian, among the aristocrats versed in the various arts. Period sources mention in particular painting competitions (e-awase) where the nobles competed around a common theme from a poem, as described by Murasaki Shikibu in the the Tale of Genji. Their work seems to focus more on the illustration of novels (monogatari) and diaries (nikki), rather feminine literature of the court. Monks were also able to produce paintings without any patronage.
Secondly, in medieval Japan there were professional painters' workshops (絵 所, literally "painting office"); during the Kamakura period, professional production dominated greatly, and several categories of workshops were distinguished: those officially attached to the palace (kyūtei edokoro), those attached to the great temples and shrines (jiin edokoro), or finally those hosted by a few senior figures. The study of certain colophons and period texts makes it possible to associate many emakimono with these professional workshops, and even sometimes to understand how they function.
When produced by the temple workshops, emakimono were intended mainly as proselytism, or to disseminate a doctrine, or even as an act of faith, because copying illustrated sutras must allow communion with the deities (a theory even accredits the idea that the Kitano Tenjin Engi Emaki would have aimed to pacify evil spirits). Proselytising, favoured by the emergence of the Pure Land Buddhist sects during the Kamakura era, changed the methods of emakimono production, because works of proselytism were intended to be copied and disseminated widely in many associated temples, explaining the large number of more or less similar copies on the lives of great monks and the founding of the important temples.
Various historians emphasise the use of emakimono in sessions of picture explaining (絵 解, e-toki), during which a learned monk detailed the contents of the scrolls to a popular audience. Specialists thus explicate the unusually large dimensions of the different versions of the Kitano Tenjin Engi Emaki or the Ippen Shonin Eden. As for the workshops of the court, they satisfied the orders of the palace, whether for the illustration of novels or historical chronicles, such as the Heiji Monogatari Emaki. A form of exploitation of the story could also motivate the sponsor: for example, Heiji Monogatari Emaki were produced for the Minamoto clan (winner of the Genpei War), and the Mōko Shūrai Ekotoba was created to extol the deeds of a samurai in search of recognition from the shogun. These works were, it seems, intended to be read by nobles. Nevertheless, Seckel and Hasé assert that the separation between the secular and the religious remains unclear and undoubtedly does not correspond to an explicit practice: thus, the aristocrats regularly ordered emakimono to offer them to a temple, and the religious scrolls do not refrain from representing popular things. So, for example, the Hōnen Shonin Eden presents a rich overview of medieval civilization.
Colophons and comparative studies sometimes allow us to deduce the name of the artist of an emakimono: for example, the monk En'i signed the Ippen Shonin Eden, historians designate Tokiwa Mitsunaga as the author of the Ban Dainagon Ekotoba and the Nenjū Gyōji Emaki, or Enichibō Jōnin for part of the Kegon Engi Emaki. Nevertheless, the life of these artists remains poorly known, at most they seem to be of noble extraction. Such a background is particularly implied by the always very precise depictions in emakimono of the imperial palace (interior architecture, clothing and rituals) or official bodies (notably the imperial police (検非違使, kebiishi)). The Shigisan Engi Emaki illustrates that point well, as the precision of both religious and aristocratic motifs suggests that the painter is really close to those two worlds.
Perhaps a more famous artist is Fujiwara no Nobuzane, aristocrat of the Fujiwara clan and author of the Zuijin Teiki Emaki, as well as various suites of realistic portraits ("likeness pictures" (似絵, nise-e), a school he founded in honour of his father Fujiwara no Takanobu). Among the temple workshops, we know that the Kōzan-ji workshop was particularly prolific, under the leadership of the monk Myōe, a great scholar who brought in many works from Song dynasty China. Thus, the Jōnin brushstrokes on the Kegon Engi Emaki or the portrait of Myōe reveal the first Song influences in Japanese painting. However, the crucial lack of information and documents on these rare known artists leads Japanese art historians rather to identify styles, workshops, and schools of production.
From the 14th century, the Imperial Court Painting Bureau (宮廷絵所, Kyūtei edokoro), and even for a time the edokoro of the shogun, were headed by the Tosa school, which, as mentioned above, continued Yamato-e painting and the manufacture of emakimono despite the decline of the genre. The Tosa school artists are much better known; Tosa Mitsunobu, for example, produced a large number of works commissioned by temples (including the Kiyomizu-dera Engi Emaki) or nobles (including the Gonssamen kassen emaki). The competing Kanō school also offered a such few pieces, on command: art historians have shown strong similarities between the Heiji Monogatari Emaki (12th century) and the Tōshō Daigongen Engi (17th century) by Kanō Tan'yū of the Kanō school, probably to suggest a link between the Minamoto and Tokugawa clans, members of which were, respectively, the first and last shoguns who ruled all of Japan.
Materials and manufacture
The preferred support medium for emakimono is paper, and to a lesser extent silk; both originate from China , although Japanese paper (washi) is generally of a more solid texture and less delicate than Chinese paper (the fibres are longer). The is traditionally made with the help of women of the Japanese archipelago.
The most famous colors are taken from mineral pigments: for example azurite for blue, vermilion for red, realgar for yellow, malachite for green, etc. These thick pigments, named iwa-enogu in Japanese, are not soluble in water and require a thick binder, generally an animal glue; the amount of glue required depends on how finely the pigments have been ground.
As emakimono are intended to be rolled up, the colours must be applied to them in a thin, flat layer in order to avoid any cracking in the medium term, which limits the use of patterns (reliefs) predominant in Western painting. As for the ink, also invented in China around the first century CE, it results from a simple mixture of binder and wood smoke, the dosage of which depends on the manufacturer. Essential for calligraphy, it is also important in Asian pictorial arts where the line often takes precedence; Japanese artists apply it with a brush, varying the thickness of the line and the dilution of the ink to produce a colour from a dark black to a pale gray strongly absorbed by the paper.
Scrolls of paper or tissue remain relatively fragile, in particular after the application of paint. Emakimono are therefore lined with one or more layers of strong paper, in a very similar way to kakemono (Japanese hanging scrolls): the painted paper or silk is stretched, glued onto the lining, and then dried and brushed, normally by a specialized craftsman, known as a kyōshi (literally "master in sutra"). The long format of emakimono poses specific problems: generally, sheets of painted paper or silk two or three metres long are lined separately, then assembled using strips of long-fibre Japanese paper, known for its strength. The lining process simply requires the application of an animal glue which, as it dries, also allows the painted paper or silk to be properly stretched. Assembly of the emakimono is finalised by the selection of the wooden rod (軸, jiku), which is quite thin, and the connection of the cover (表 紙, hyōshi), which protects the work once it is rolled up with a cord (紐, himo); for the most precious pieces painted with gold and silver powder, a further protective blanket is often made of silk and decorated on the inside (見 返 し, mikaeshi, literally "inside cover").
The currents and techniques of emakimono art are intimately linked and most often part of the yamato-e movement, readily opposed at the beginning to Chinese-style paintings, known as kara-e. Yamato-e, a colorful and decorative everyday art, strongly typifies the output of the time. Initially, yamato-e mainly designated works with Japanese themes, notably court life, ceremonies or archipelago landscapes, in opposition to the hitherto dominant Chinese scholarly themes, especially during the Nara period. The documents of the 9th century mention, for example, the paintings on sliding walls and screens of the then Imperial Palace, which illustrate waka poems. Subsequently, the term yamato-e referred more generally to all of the Japanese style paintings created in the 9th century that expressed the sensitivity and character of the people of the archipelago, including those extending beyond the earlier themes. Miyeko Murase thus speaks of "the emergence of national taste".
Different currents of paintings are part of the yamato-e according to the times (about the 10th and 14th centuries), and are found in emakimono. The style, composition and technique vary greatly, but it is possible to identify major principles. Thus, in relation to style, the Heian period produced a contrast between refined court painting and dynamic painting of subjects outside the court, while the Kamakura period saw a synthesis of the two approaches and the contribution of new realistic influences of the Chinese wash paintings of the Song dynasty. In relation to composition, the artists could alternate calligraphy and painting so as to illustrate only the most striking moments of the story, or else create long painted sections where several scenes blended together and flowed smoothly. Finally, in relation to technique, the classification of emakimono, although complex, allows us to identify two approaches: paintings favoring colour, and those favoring line for the purpose of dynamism.
The particular format of the emakimono, long strips of paintings without fixed limits, requires solving a number of compositional problems in order to maintain the ease and clarity of the narrative, and which have given rise to a coherent art form over several centuries. In summary, according to E. Saint-Marc: "We had to build a vocabulary, a syntax, solve a whole series of technical problems, invent a discipline that is both literary and plastic, an aesthetic mode which finds its conventions [...] in turn invented and modelled, frozen by use, then remodelled, to make it an instrument of refined expression."
The sections below attempt to explore the pictorial techniques that have gradually become anchored in the art of emakimono or yamato-e.
Styles and techniques
Overview of the Heian period yamato-e styles
The specialists like to distinguish between two currents in the yamato-e, and thus in the emakimono, of the Heian period, namely the onna-e ("painting of woman", onna meaning "woman"), and otoko-e ("painting of man", otoko meaning "man"). In the Heian period, these two currents of yamato-e also echoed the mysteries and the seclusion of the Imperial Court: the onna-e style thus told what happened inside the court, and the otoko-e style spoke of happenings in the populace outside.
Court style: onna-e
Onna-e fully transcribed the lyrical and refined aesthetic of the court, which was characterized by a certain restraint, introspection and the expression of feelings, bringing together above all works inspired by "romantic" literature such as the Genji Monogatari Emaki. The dominant impression of this genre is expressed in Japanese by the term mono no aware, a kind of fleeting melancholy born from the feeling of the impermanence of things. These works mainly adopted the so - called tsukuri-e (constructed painting) technique, with rich and opaque colours. In emakimono of the 13th century, in which the onna-e style was brought up-to-date, the same technique was used but in a sometimes less complete manner, the colours more directly expressing feelings and the artists using a more decorative aesthetic, as, e.g., with the very important use of gold dust in the Murasaki Shikibu Diary Emaki.
A characteristic element of the onna-e resides in the drawing of the faces, very impersonal, that specialists often compare to noh masks. Indeed, according to the hikime kagibana technique, two or three lines were enough to represent the eyes and the nose in a stylized way; E. Grilli notes the melancholy of this approach. The desired effect is still uncertain, but probably reflects the great restraint of feelings and personalities in the palace, or even allows readers to identify more easily with the characters. In some monogatari of the Heian period, the artists rather expressed the feelings or the passions in the positions as well as in the pleats and folds of the clothes, in harmony with the mood of the moment.
Tsukiri-e painting in lighter tones
Murasaki Shikibu Diary Emaki, 13th century
Ise Monogatari Emaki, 14th century
Court scene illustrating hikime kagibana, a technique of inexpressive and impersonal representation of faces
Genji Monogatari Emaki, 12th century
Popular style: otoko-e
The current of the otoko-e was freer and more lively than the onna-e, representing battles, historical chronicles, epics and religious legends by favouring long illustrations over calligraphy, as in the Shigisan Engi Emaki or the Heiji Monogatari Emaki. The style was based on soft lines drawn freely by the artist in ink, unlike the tsukuri-e constructed paintings, to favour the impression of movement. The colours generally appeared more muted and left the paper bare in places.
If the term onna-e is well attested in the texts of the time, and seems to come from the illustrations of novels by the ladies of the court from the 10th century, the origins of the otoko-e are more obscure: they arise a priori from the interest of the nobles in Japanese provincial life from the 11th century, as well as from local folk legends; moreover, several very detailed scenes from the Shigisan Engi Emaki clearly show that its author can only have been a palace regular, aristocrat or monk. In any case, there are still several collections of these folk tales of the time, such as the Konjaku Monogatarishū.
Unlike the court paintings, the more spontaneous scrolls such as the Shigisan Engi Emaki or the Ban Dainagon Ekotoba display much more realism in the drawing of the characters, and depict, e.g. humour and burlesque; people's feelings (anger, joy, fear, etc.) are expressed more spontaneously and directly.
Popular scene in which the lines take precedence over very light colors
Shigisan Engi Emaki, 12th century
Another painting of a popular subject favouring the lines
Kokawa-dera Engi Emaki, 12th century
Expressive painting of a communal crowd
Ban Dainagon Ekotoba, late 12th century
Humorous scene depicting a doctor's mistake
Yamai no Sōshi, 12th century
Kamakura period realist painting
During the Kamakura period, the two currents of yamato-e (onna-e and otoko-e) mingled and gave birth to works that are both dynamic and vividly coloured, in the manner of the Kitano Tenjin Engi Emaki. Furthermore, the majority of emakimono also transcribed the realistic tendencies of the time, according to the tastes of the warriors in power. The Heiji Monogatari Emaki thus shows in great detail the weapons, armour and uniforms of the soldiers, and the Ban Dainagon Ekotoba individually portrays the more than two hundred panicked figures who appear on the section depicting the fire at the door.
Realistic painting is best displayed in the portraits known as nise-e, a movement initiated by Fujiwara no Takanobu and his son Fujiwara no Nobuzane. These two artists and their descendants produced a number of emakimono of a particular genre: they were suites of portraits of famous people made in a rather similar style, i.e. with almost geometric simplicity of the clothes, and extreme realism of the face. The essence of the nise-e was really to capture the intimate personality of the subject with great economy.
Among the most famous nise-e scrolls are the Tennō Sekkan Daijin Eizukan, composed of 131 portraits of emperors, governors, ministers and senior courtiers (by Fujiwara no Tamenobu and Fujiwara no Gōshin, 14th century), and the Zuijin Teiki Emaki by Nobuzane, whose ink painting (hakubyō) enhanced with very discreet colour illustrates perfectly the nise-e lines. Additionally, there is the Sanjūrokkasen Emaki, a work of a more idealized than realistic style, which forms a portrait gallery of the Thirty-Six Immortals of Poetry. More generally, humans are one of the elementary subjects of emakimono, and many works of the Kamakura period incorporate nise-e techniques, such as the Heiji Monogatari Emaki or the Mōko Shūrai Ekotoba.
Colours and dynamism
Kitano Tenjin Engi Emaki, 13th century
Detail of painting of very realistic warriors in faces, weapons and armor
Heiji Monogatari Emaki, 13th century
Nise-e portrait of the waka poet Saigū Nyōgo
Sanjūrokkasen Emaki, 13th century
Chinese landscape and Song dynasty wash paintings
The yamato-e style therefore characterised almost all emakimono, and Chinese painting no longer provided the themes and techniques. However, influences were still noticeable in certain works of the Kamakura period, in particular the art, so famous today, of the Song dynasty wash paintings, which was fully demonstrated in the grandiose and deep landscapes sketched in ink, by Ienaga. Borrowings also remained visible in religious scrolls such as the Kegon Engi Emaki or the Ippen Shonin Eden. This last work presents many landscapes typical of Japan according to a perspective and a rigorous realism, with a great economy of colors; various Song pictorial techniques are used to suggest depth, such as birds' flights disappearing on the horizon or the background gradually fading.
Steep mountain landscape and hermitage
Kiyomizu-dera Engi Emaki, 1517
Zenmyō, a young Chinese woman, confesses her love to the monk Gishō during his stay in China
Kegon Engi Emaki, 13th century
Spatial and temporal composition
Transitions between scenes
The juxtaposition of the text and the painting constitutes a key point of the narrative aspect of emakimono. Originally, in the illustrated sutras, the image was organized in a long, continuous frieze at the top of the scroll, above the texts. That approach, however, was quickly abandoned for a more open layout, of which there are three types:
- alternation between texts and paintings (danraku-shiki), the former endeavouring to transcribe the illustrations chosen by the artist. Court style paintings (onna-e) often opted for this approach, as paintings more readily focused on important moments or conveyed a narrative.
- intermittence, where the texts appeared only at the beginning or at the end of the scroll, giving pride of place to continuous illustrations (rusōgata-shiki or renzoku-shiki). This type was often used in epic and historical chronicles; the best-known examples are the Shigisan Engi Emaki and the Heiji Monogatari Emaki. Sometimes, the texts were even hosted by a separate handscroll.
- paintings interspersed with text, ie the text was placed above the people who were speaking, as in the Buddhist accounts of the Dōjō-ji Engi Emaki, the Kegon Gojūgo-sho Emaki or the Tengu Zōshi Emaki. Here we can see the beginnings of speech balloons in modern comics.
Painting in frieze above the text, a form of Chinese origin that was quickly abandoned
Illustrated Sutra of Cause and Effect, 8th century
Text before the painting
Obusuma Saburo Emaki, 8th century
Text located in a box at the top of the scroll
Kegon Gojūgo-sho Emaki, 12th century
Scene in which the characters' words are written directly in the painting, above them
Kegon Engi Emaki, 13th century
Alternation between text and painting – Hell Scroll of Nara National Museum, 12th century
Succession of painted scenes without textual demarcation – Chōjū-jinbutsu-giga, 12th century
Succession of painted scenes, with only two sections of text at the beginning and at the end – Heiji Monogatari Emaki, 13th century
Perspective and point of view
The space in the composition constitutes a second important spring of the narration with time. As the scroll is usually read from right to left and top to bottom, the authors mainly adopt plunging points of view (chōkan, “bird's-eye perspective”). However, the low height of the emaki forces the artist to set up tricks such as the use of long diagonal vanishing lines or sinuous curves suggesting depth.
Long vanishing line guiding eye movement
Shigisan Engi Emaki, 12th century
Scene in which depth is carried by parallel diagonals (here architecture), without perspective
Genji Monogatari Emaki, 12th century
Example of a simple transition using a watercourse
Illustrated Sutra of Cause and Effect, 8th century
Interior view, in which the roof is not shown (fukinuki yatai)
Ban Dainagon Ekotoba, 12th century
Scale variation, where the main character appears very tall compared with the mountain; opaque mists are also characteristic of Asian art
Kitano Tenjin Engi Emaki, 1219
Art historians, in their writings, have repeatedly emphasized the specific techniques of emakimono art through some characteristic scrolls, presented in this section.
Genji Monogatari Emaki
The Genji Monogatari Emaki, dated approximately between the years 1120 and 1140, illustrate the famous Tale of Genji in the refined and intimate style of the court (onna-e), but only a few fragments of four scrolls remain today. The scene shown here depicts Prince Genji's final visit to his dying beloved, Lady Murasaki. In the composition, the diagonals reveal the emotion of the characters. First, Lady Murasaki appears at the top right, then the lines guide the eye to the prince in the lower centre, who appears to be crushed by sorrow. Then, the reading continues, and, at left, several months have passed, showing the garden of lovers devastated by time, echoing the loved one lost. The colors are darker than usual. In this scene, all of the classic pictorial elements of the emakimono of the onna-e genre are visible: the diagonals that guide the eye, the fukinuki yatai, the hikime kagibana, and the colours affixed evenly over the entire surface, with the tsukuri-e technique.
Shigisan Engi Emaki
The Shigisan Engi Emaki provides a popular and humorous narrative of three episodes from the life of the Buddhist monk Myōren (founder of Chōgosonshi-ji), emphasizing the line and light colors of the otoko-e. The most precise estimates place it between 1157 and 1180, and the quality of the descriptions of the temples and the palace suggests that the artist is familiar with both ecclesiastical and aristocratic circles. Myōren, who lived as a hermit in the mountains of Kyoto, used to send a magic bowl by air to the nearby village, in order to receive his offering of rice. One day, a rich merchant became tired of this ritual and locked the bowl in his attic. To punish him, Myōren blew up the whole granary containing the village harvest, as painted in the scene shown here; in that scene, known as the flying granary, the artist fully represents the popular feelings, fear and panic at seeing the harvest disappear. The movements of the crowd and the expressive, almost burlesque faces of the landscapes contrast with the tangible restraint in the Genji Monogatari Emaki. So, this emakimono fits into the otoko-e genre, marked by dynamic ink lines, light colors revealing the paper, and themes of everyday life.
Heiji Monogatari Emaki
The Heiji Monogatari Emaki recounts the historical events of the Heiji rebellion, an episode in the civil war between the Taira and Minamoto clans at the end of the Heian era. Of the numerous original scrolls, formed in the second half of the thirteenth century, probably over several decades, only three remain, together with various fragments. The first scroll, which depicts the Siege of Sanjō Palace, is one of the most renowned in the art of emakimono, due to its mastery of movement and setting up of the narrative to the climax: the fire, which spreads over almost the entire height of the scroll in the scene shown here. At the seat of the fire, extremely realistically represented soldiers, equipped with weapons and armor, fight violently, while the aristocrats who try to flee are savagely massacred (here, one is slaughtered by a shaggy soldier). The palace fire echoes that in another, older, scroll, the Ban Dainagon Ekotoba, which is renowned for its mix of colorful and refined scenes.
Ippen Shonin Eden
The twelve scrolls of the Ippen Shonin Eden narrate the biography of the holy monk Ippen, founder of the Ji shū school of Pure Land Buddhism. They were painted in 1299 by the monk-painter En'i, disciple of Ippen, on silk, probably because of the importance of the character. Ippen, cantor of salvation for all souls and dancing prayers (nenbutsu odori), travelled throughout Japan to transmit his doctrine to men, peasants, townspeople and nobles. The emakimono is renowned for its many strong scenes of landscapes typical of Japan, so realistic that they can still be recognised perfectly today. The scene shown here, in which Ippen and his disciples arrive at Kyoto by the bridge over the Kamo River, illustrates the unique emakimono style, which draws its inspiration from both the classic yamato-e realism of Kamakura art and the wash painting of the Song dynasty. The result, so admired by specialists, appears very close to deep and spiritual Chinese landscapes with rough ink strokes, while retaining a Japanese iconography through the freedom taken with perspective (the characters in particular are disproportionate) and the elements of daily life.
Kegon Engi Emaki
The Kegon Engi Emaki, painted around 1218-1230, illustrates the legend of two Korean monks who founded the Kegon sect in their country in the twelfth century. One of them, Gishō, made a pilgrimage to China in his youth to complete his Buddhist education. There, he met a young Chinese girl, Zenmyō, who fell in love with him. Alas, on the day he was due to depart, the latter arrived late at the port and, in despair, rushed into the water, swearing to protect her beloved forever. She then transformed into a dragon and became a protective deity of the Kegon school, according to legend. The well-known scene shown here, in which Zenmyō, transformed into a dragon, carries Gishō's ship on her back, features supple and fine lines as well as discreet colors that do not mask the brushstrokes; this style also seems inspired by the wash painting of the Song dynasty to which the very Japanese sensitivity for colors has been added. In fact, the sponsor of the roll, the monk Myōe of Kōzan-ji, appreciated the art of the Asian continent and brought to Japan several contemporary Chinese works, which probably inspired the artists of his painting workshop.
Kitano Tenjin Engi Emaki
The original scrolls of the Kitano Tenjin Engi Emaki, reporting the facts about the life and death of Sugawara no Michizane, scholarly minister to the Emperor during his lifetime, and deified according to legend as a kami of studies and letters, demonstrate a sensitivity in mixing Buddhism and, above all, Shinto. The scrolls were actually intended for the Shinto shrine of Kitano Tenmangū in Kyoto; the last two of eight scrolls narrate the foundation and miracles. However, the thematic division of the work appears unfinished, the sketch of a ninth scroll having been brought to light. In the scene shown here, Michizane, unjustly condemned to exile, calls out to the gods in his misfortune. The composition of the painting testifies to a very Japanese sensitivity; Michizane is disproportionately depicted to underline his grandeur and determination in the face of dishonour, while the vividly colored and almost contourless (mokkotsu) landscape is imbued with Shinto animism. The mists resembling long opaque ribbons are further features of emakimono, although also present in a different form in Chinese art.
- Willmann 2012n.
- "Entry Details for 絵巻物". 楽しい Japanese. Retrieved 11 December 2020.
- Grilli 1962, p. 6.
- Okudaira 1973, pp. 75–78.
- Iwao & Iyanaga 2002, vol. 1.
- Ienaga 1973, pp. 107–108.
- Grilli 1962, p. 4.
- Swann 1967, p. 62–67.
- Shimizu 2001, p. 85–86.
- Frédéric, Louis (2002). Japan Encyclopedia. Harvard University Press. p. 456. ISBN 978-0-674-01753-5.
- Murase 1996, p. 67.
- Reischauer, Edwin O. (1989). Japan: The Story of a Nation (4th ed.). New York: Alfred A. Knopf. ISBN 0394585275.
- Payne, Richard K. (1999). "At Midlife in Medieval Japan". Japanese Journal of Religious Studies. 26 (1/2): 135–157. JSTOR 30233611.
- Murase 1996, pp. 119–120, 127–128.
- Shively, Donald H.; McCullough, William H. (1999). The Cambridge History of Japan: Heian Japan. 2. Cambridge University Press. p. 13. ISBN 978-0-521-22353-9.
- Murase 1996, p. 119.
- Encyclopædia Britannica. 22 (15th ed.). 1998. pp. 275–276.
- Terukazu 1961, pp. 53–60.
- Soper, Alexander C. (1942). "The Rise of Yamato-e". The Art Bulletin. 24 (4): 351–379. doi:10.1080/00043079.1942.11409363. JSTOR 3046846.
- Terukazu 1961, pp. 66–67.
- Terukazu 1961, pp. 68–69.
- Terukazu, Akiyama (1993). "The Door Paintings in the Phoenix Hall of the Byōdōin as Yamatoe". Artibus Asiae. 53 (1/2): 144–167. doi:10.2307/3250512. JSTOR 3250512.
- Ienaga 1973, p. 94.
- Okudaira 1973, pp. 22–25.
- Shimizu 2001, pp. 146–148.
- Elisseeff & Elisseeff 1980, p. 272.
- Elisseeff & Elisseeff 1980, p. 275.
- Seckel & Hasé 1959, p. 68.
- Stanley-Baker 1990, p. 84. sfn error: no target: CITEREFStanley-Baker1990 (help)
- Ienaga 1973, p. 140.
- Terukazu, Akiyama (1985). "Expression et technique dans le rouleau enluminé de l'Histoire de Gengi". Comptes-rendus des séances de l'Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres (in French) (4): 565–571..
- Seckel & Hasé 1959, pp. 44–45.
- Shirahata, Yoshi (1969). "寢覺物語繪卷, 駒競行幸繪卷, 小野雪見御幸繪卷, 伊勢物語繪卷, なよ竹物語繪卷, 葉月物語繪卷, 豐明繪草子". Shinshū Nihon emakimono zenshū (in Japanese). 17. Kadokawa Shoten: 4–12. OCLC 768947820. Cite journal requires
- Okudaira 1973, p. 53.
- Swann 1967, pp. 122–123.
- Lésoualc'h 1967, pp. 42–43.
- Ienaga 1973, pp. 102–103.
- Murase 1996, p. 136.
- Okudaira 1973, p. 29.
- Lésoualc'h 1967, p. 45–46.
- Grilli 1962, p. 11.
- Reischauer 1989.
- Iwao & Iyanaga 2002, Vol 2, p 2260.
- Swann 1967, p. 125.
- Shimizu 2001, p. 193.
- Nakano, Chieko (2009). "Kechien" as religious praxis in medieval Japan: Picture scrolls as the means and sites of salvation (PhD dissertation). University of Arizona. p. 14. Retrieved 11 December 2020.
- Okudaira 1973, p. 32.
- Okudaira 1962, pp. 98–102.
- Ienaga 1973, p. 125.
- Lésoualc'h 1967, pp. 41–42.
- Sumpter 2009.
- Swann 1967, pp. 102-106.
- Okudaira 1973, pp. 33–34.
- Shimizu 2001, pp. 196–197.
- Terukazu 1961, pp. 95–98.
- Murase 1996, p. 160.
- Seckel & Hasé 1959, p. 16.
- "Nise-e 似絵". JAANUS (Japanese Architecture and Art Net Users System). Retrieved 8 November 2011.
- Shimizu 2001, pp. 185–187.
- Akiyama 1971.
- Shimizu 2001, pp. 195–196.
- Mason & Dinwiddie 2005, pp. 201–203.
- Yoshikawa, Itsuji (1976). Major Themes in Japanese Art. The Heibonsha Survey of Japanese Art. 1. Weatherhill. pp. 120–121. ISBN 978-0-8348-1003-7.
- Allen, Laura Warantz (1995). "Images of the Poet Saigyō as Recluse". Journal of Japanese Studies. The Society for Japanese Studies. 21 (1): 65–102. doi:10.2307/133086. JSTOR 133086.
- Murase 1996, pp. 163–164.
- Okudaira 1973, p. 131.
- Shimizu 2001, p. 194.
- Terukazu 1961, p. 100–101.
- Iwao & Iyanaga 2002, Vol 1.
- Mason & Dinwiddie 2005, p. 217–226.
- Sayre, Charles Franklin (1982). "Japanese Court-Style Narrative Painting of the Late Middle Ages". Archives of Asian Art. 35: 71–81. JSTOR 20111127.
- Araki, James T. (1981). "Otogi-Zōshi and Nara-Ehon: A Field of Study in Flux". Monumenta Nipponica. 36 (1): 1–20. doi:10.2307/2384084. JSTOR 2384084.
- Elisseeff & Elisseeff 1980, p. 278–279.
- Elisseeff & Elisseeff 1980, p. 286.
- Toda, Kenji (1930). "The Picture Books of Nara". Bulletin of the Art Institute of Chicago. 24 (3): 32–33.
- Grilli 1962, p. 12.
- Gerhart, Karen M. (1999). The Eyes of Power: Art and early Tokugawa authority. University of Hawaii Press. pp. 127–128. ISBN 978-0-8248-2178-4.
- Karetzky, Patricia Eichenbaum (2000). Early Buddhist Narrative Art:Illustrations of the life of the Buddha from Central Asia to China, Korea, and Japan. University Press of America. pp. 157–158. ISBN 978-0-7618-1671-3.
- Ienaga 1973, pp. 160–162.
- Seckel & Hasé 1959, pp. 41–43.
- Seckel & Hasé 1959, pp. 39–41.
- "edokoro". Japanese Architecture and Art Net Users System (JAANUS). Retrieved 10 January 2021.
- Terukazu, Akiyama (1971). "New Buddhist Sects and Emakimono (Handscroll Painting) in the Kamakura Period". Acta Artistica. 2: 62–76.
- Sieffert, René. "Heiji monogatari" (in French). Encyclopædia Universalis. Retrieved 10 January 2021.
- Illouz 1985, pp. 12–14.
- Yamasaki, Kazuo; Emoto, Yoshimichi (1979). "Pigments Used on Japanese Paintings from the Protohistoric Period through the 17th Century". Ars Orientalis. University of Michigan. 11: 1–14. JSTOR 4629293.
- Illouz 1985, pp. 83–88.
- Seckel & Hasé 1959, pp. 18–20.
- Illouz 1985, pp. 92–94.
- Illouz 1985, pp. 116–118.
- 青柳正規 (Masanori Aoyagi) (1997). 日本美術館 (Nihon bijutsukan, lit. "Museum of Japanese Art"). Shōgakkan. p. 560. ISBN 978-4-09-699701-7.
- Ienaga 1973, pp. 9–11.
- Saint-Marc 2000, pp. 124–125.
- Stanley-Baker 2014, Chapter 4.
- Okudaira 1973, pp. 52–53.
- Mason & Dinwiddie 2005, pp. 183–185.
- Okudaira 1973, pp. 70–71.
- Elisseeff 1980, p. 276. sfn error: no target: CITEREFElisseeff1980 (help)
- Lesoualc’h 1967, pp. 41–42. sfn error: no target: CITEREFLesoualc’h1967 (help)
- Okudaira 1973, pp. 56–57.
- Lesoualc’h 1967, pp. 42–43. sfn error: no target: CITEREFLesoualc’h1967 (help)
- Terukazu 1961, pp. 76–77.
- Terukazu 1961, pp. 81–83.
- "Nise-e". Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved 16 January 2021.
- Ienaga 1973, pp. 121–122.
- Murase 1996, pp. 159–162.
- Saint-Marc 2001.
- Grilli 1962, pp. 7–8.
- Terukazu 1985. sfn error: multiple targets (2×): CITEREFTerukazu1985 (help)
- Mason & Dinwiddie 2005, pp. 116–118.
- Shibusawa 1984.
- Okudaira 1973, pp. 135–137.
- Grilli 1962, p. 13.
- Tomita 1925.
- Murase 1996.
- Kaufman 1983.
- Mason & Dinwiddie 2005, pp. 198–200.
- Terukazu 1961, pp. 89–90.
- Lésoualc'h 1967.
Journal articles and conference proceedings
- Armbruster, Gisela (1972). "Cassoni-Emaki: A Comparative Study". Artibus Asiae. 34 (1): 29–61+63–70. doi:10.2307/3249637. JSTOR 3249637.
- Kaufman, Laura S. (1983). Lyrical Imagery and Religious Content in Japanese Art: The Pictorial Biography of Ippen the Holy Man in Traditions in Contact and Change. XIVth Congress of the International Association for the History of Religions (1980). pp. 201–230. ISBN 9780889201422.
- Milone, Marco (August 2020). "Pittura a rotoli". Linus (in Italian): 68–70. ISBN 978-8893886901.
- Murase, Miyeko (1993). "The "Taiheiki Emaki": The Use of the Past". Artibus Asiae. 53 (1/2): 262–289. doi:10.2307/3250519. JSTOR 3250519.
- Saint-Marc, Elsa (2001). "Techniques de composition de l'espace dans l'Ippen hijiri-e". Arts Asiatiques (in French). 56: 91–109. doi:10.3406/arasi.2001.1466.
- Sayre, Charles Franklin (1982). "Japanese Court-Style Narrative Painting of the Late Middle Ages". Archives of Asian Art. Duke University Press. 35: 71–81. JSTOR 20111127.
- Shibusawa, Keizo; et al. (1984). "Pictopedia of Everyday Life in Medieval Japan compiled from picture scrolls" (PDF). Report of "Systematization of Nonwritten Cultural Materials for the Study of Human Societies". Kanagawa University.
- Strauch-Nelson, Wendy (May 2008). "Emaki: Japanese Picture Scrolls". Art Education. National Art Education Association. 61 (3): 25–32. doi:10.1080/00043125.2008.11652057. JSTOR 27696294. S2CID 158869725.
- Sumpter, Sara L. (December 2009). "The Shôkyû Version of the Kitano Tenjin Engi Emaki: A brief introduction to its content and function" (PDF). Eras Journal. 11. ISSN 1445-5218.
- Terukazu, Akiyama (1971). "New Buddhist Sects and Emakimono (Handscroll Painting) in the Kamakura Period". Acta Artistica. 2: 62–76.
- Terukazu, Akiyama (1985). "Expression et technique dans le rouleau enluminé de l'Histoire de Gengi". Comptes-rendus des séances de l'Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres (in French) (4): 565–571.
- Tomita, Kojiro (1925). "The Burning of the Sanjō Palace (Heiji Monogatari): A Japanese Scroll Painting of the Thirteenth Century". Museum of Fine Arts Bulletin. Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. 23 (139): 49–55.
- Watanabe, Masako (1998). "Narrative Framing in the "Tale of Genji Scroll": Interior Space in the Compartmentalized Emaki". Artibus Asiae. 58 (1/2): 115–145. doi:10.2307/3249997. JSTOR 3249997.
- Waters, Virginia Skord (1997). "Sex, Lies, and the Illustrated Scroll: The Dojoji Engi Emaki". Monumenta Nipponica. Sophia University. 52 (1): 59–84. doi:10.2307/2385487. JSTOR 2385487.
Works specialising in emaki
- Department of Asian Art (October 2002). "Heian Period (794–1185)". Metropolitan Museum of Art. Timeline of Art History. Retrieved 9 December 2020.
- Grilli, Elise (1962). Rouleaux peints japonais (in French). Translated by Requien, Marcel. Arthaud.
- Milone, Marco (5 June 2020). Per un introduzione sugli emaki (in Italian). Mimesis edizioni. ISBN 978-8857565521.
- Murase, Miyeko (1983). Emaki, Narrative Scrolls from Japan. Asia Society. ISBN 978-0-87848-060-9.
- Okudaira, Hideo (1962). Emaki: Japanese picture scrolls. C. E. Tuttle Co.
- Okudaira, Hideo (1973). Narrative Picture Scrolls. Arts of Japan series. 5. Translated by Ten Grotenhuis, Elizabeth. Weatherhill. ISBN 978-0-8348-2710-3.
- Seckel, Dietrich; Hasé, Akihisa (1959). Emaki. Translated by Guerne, Armel. Delpire.
- Terukazu, Akiyama (1968). 絵卷物 [Emakimono]. Genshoku Nihon no bijutsu series (in Japanese). 8. Shōgakkan.
- Toda, Kenji (1969). Japanese Scroll Painting. Greenwood Press.
- Willmann, Anna (April 2012). "Yamato-e Painting". Metropolitan Museum of Art. Timeline of Art History. Retrieved 9 December 2020.
- Willmann, Anna (November 2012). "Japanese Illustrated Handscrolls". Metropolitan Museum of Art. Timeline of Art History. Retrieved 9 December 2020.CS1 maint: date and year (link)
Works focusing on a specific emaki
- Chan, Yuk-yue (2006). Dream, pilgrimage and dragons in the Kegon Engi Emaki (illustrated legends of the Kegon patriarchs): reading ideology in Kamakura Buddhist narrative scrolls (Thesis). University of Hong Kong. doi:10.5353/th_b3585305.
- Kaufman, Laura S. (1980). Ippen Hijiri-e: Artistic and Literary Sources in a Buddhist Handscroll Painting of Thirteenth-Century Japan (Thesis). New York University.
- Mason, Penelope E. (1977). A Reconstruction of the Hōgen-Heiji Monogatari Emaki (Thesis). Garland Science / New York University.
- Murase, Miyeko (1962). The Tenjin Engi Scrolls: A study of their genealogical relationship (Thesis). Columbia University.
- Saint-Marc, Elsa (2000). L'Ippen hijiri-e (rouleaux peints du renonçant Ippen): la mise en image d'une biographie (Thesis). Institut national des langues et civilisations orientales.
- Shirane, Haruo (2008). Envisioning the Tale of Genji: Media, gender, and cultural production. Columbia University Press. ISBN 978-0-231-14237-3.
General books on the art of Japan
- Elisseeff, Danielle; Elisseeff, Vadime (1980). L'Art de l'ancien Japon (in French). Paris: Éditions Mazenod. p. 680. ISBN 2-85088-010-8.
- Ienaga, Saburō (1973). Painting in the Yamato Style. The Heibonsha Survey of Japanese Art series. 10. Weatherhill. p. 162. ISBN 978-0-8348-1016-7.
- Illouz, Claire (1985). Les Sept Trésors du lettré: les matériaux de la peinture chinoise et japonaise. Les trésors de l'Asie series (in French). éditions Erec. p. 136. ISBN 978-2-905519-03-0.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Iwao, Seiichi; Iyanaga, Teizo (2002). Dictionnaire historique du Japon (in French). 1–2. Maisonneuve et Larose. ISBN 978-2-7068-1633-8.
- Lésoualc'h, Théo (1967). La Peinture japonaise. Histoire générale de la peinture (in French). 25. Lausanne: Éditions Rencontre.
- Mason, Penelope E.; Dinwiddie, Donald (2005). History of Japanese Art. Pearson-Prentice Hall. ISBN 978-0-13-117601-0.
- Murase, Miyeko (1996). L'Art du Japon. La Pochothèque series (in French). Paris: Éditions LGF - Livre de Poche. ISBN 2-253-13054-0.
- Shimizu, Christine (2001). L'Art japonais. Tout l'art series (in French). Flammarion. ISBN 978-2-08-013701-2.
- Stanley-Baker, Joan (2014). Japanese Art. World of Art series (3rd ed.). London: Thames & Hudson. ISBN 9780500204252.
- Swann, Peter Charles (1967). Japon: de l'époque Jomon à l'époque des Tokugawa. L'art dans le monde series (in French). Translated by Tadié, Marie. Paris: Albin Michel.
- Terukazu, Akiyama (1961). La Peinture japonaise. Les trésors de l'Asie series (in French). Genève: éditions Albert Skira. p. 217.
Media related to Emakimono at Wikimedia Commons