Conversion (gridiron football)
The conversion, try (American football, also known as a point(s) after touchdown, PAT, or extra point), or convert (Canadian football) occurs immediately after a touchdown during which the scoring team is allowed to attempt to score one extra point by kicking the ball through the uprights in the manner of a field goal, or two points by bringing the ball into the end zone in the manner of a touchdown.
Attempts at a try or convert are scrimmage plays, with the ball initially placed at any point between the hash marks, at the option of the team making the attempt. The yard line that attempts are made from depends on the league and the type of try or convert being attempted.
If the try or convert is scored by kicking the ball through the uprights, the team gets an additional one point for their touchdown, bringing their total for that score from six points to seven. If two points are needed or desired, a two-point conversion may be attempted by running or passing from scrimmage. A successful touchdown conversion from scrimmage brings the score's total to eight.
Whether a team goes for one or two points, most rules regarding scrimmage downs, including scoring touchdowns and field goals, apply as if it were a normal American fourth-down or Canadian third-down play. Exceptions, including cases where the defense forces a turnover during a conversion attempt, vary between leagues and levels of play. One thing that sets the try apart from other plays in the NFL is that, apart from the actual points, ordinary statistics are not recorded on the try as they would be on a regular scrimmage play. For example, on December 4, 2016, Eric Berry of the Kansas City Chiefs made an interception on a try and physically returned it 99 yards for a defensive two-point conversion. However, because it occurred on a try, Berry did not get statistical credit for the 99 yards of return yardage; nor would a player ever be credited with passing, rushing, or receiving yardage on a try.
The try/convert is among the oldest parts of the game of gridiron football and dates to its rugby roots. In its earliest days, scoring a touchdown was not the primary objective but a means of getting a free kick at the goal (hence why the name "try", more commonly associated with rugby today, is still used in American football rule books), and thus early scoring rubrics for the game gave more points to the subsequent kick than the actual advancement of the ball over the goal line. The related term "conversion" is still used in both rugby union and rugby league to refer to extra points scored by kicking the ball through the posts after a try has been scored.
By the start of the 20th century, touchdowns had become more important and the roles of touchdown and kick were reversed. By this time the point value for the after-touchdown kick had reduced to its current one-point value while the touchdown was now worth five. (This later increased to six points in American football in 1912 and in Canadian football in 1956.)
In the first half of the 20th century, a one-point conversion could be scored either by kick or by way of a scrimmage play. Beginning in 1958, the scrimmage play conversion method of scoring became worth two points (a two-point conversion) in college football. While the American Football League adopted the college rule throughout its ten-season existence in the 1960s (as did the United States Football League throughout its three-season existence in the 1980s), other professional leagues were slow to follow suit; all levels of Canadian football did so in 1975, and the National Football League did not do so until 1994.
Although a successful kick is only worth one point, and has a very high rate of success, missed or blocked attempts can decide the outcome of the game:
- One example was the 2003 game between the New Orleans Saints and Jacksonville Jaguars where, after the Saints scored a touchdown in the multiple-lateral River City Relay as time expired, their kicker John Carney missed the extra point, giving the Jaguars a 20–19 victory.
- On October 21, 2018, with 24 seconds remaining on the clock, Baltimore Ravens kicker Justin Tucker had his first-ever missed PAT attempt, ending the game and causing the Baltimore Ravens to lose to the New Orleans Saints 24–23. This was his first missed kick out of 223 attempts. Even so, he is still the most accurate kicker in NFL history with 241 out of 242 successful attempts.
- On November 11, 1979, the New York Jets lost to the Buffalo Bills 14–12, the difference coming from two missed extra points by place kicker Toni Linhart. Linhart, who had been cut earlier in the 1979 season by the Baltimore Colts and was signed by the Jets to fill in for the injured Pat Leahy, never played another game in the NFL.
- Another 2003 game, this one between the Carolina Panthers and Tampa Bay Buccaneers, was sent to overtime after what would have been a game-winning extra point was blocked. The Panthers won the game in overtime 12–9.
- A 2005 game between the Green Bay Packers and Tampa Bay Buccaneers is another example, as the Buccaneers won 17–16, the difference being Ryan Longwell missing an extra point after a Packers touchdown.
- In the 2016 AFC Championship Game, New England Patriots placekicker Stephen Gostkowski missed an extra point in the first quarter, keeping the score at 7–6 in favor of the Denver Broncos. The Patriots were forced to go for two when they scored a touchdown late in the fourth quarter. The two-point try was intercepted, putting the Broncos in Super Bowl 50 with a 20–18 victory.
The CFL and NFL both made major changes to the rules governing conversions prior to their respective 2015 seasons, reducing or eliminating some of the differences between the two leagues.
Duration of the play
In American high school football (in most states), the play is over once the ball becomes dead or the defense takes possession. In many other levels of football, including the CFL, NFL, and American college football, the play continues after a turnover to the defense. This allows the defense to return the ball to the opponent's end zone for two points and also allows for a one-point safety. Two states, Texas and Massachusetts, play high school football under NCAA rules and thus allow the defense to score on an extra-point attempt.
Differences between leagues
In American football, the game clock does not run during an extra-point attempt, except for some rare circumstances at the high-school level (some state associations allow for the clock to run continuously in the second half if one team is leading the other by a large margin) and for arena football, which runs the clock continuously except during the final minute of each half and overtime. In Canadian football, the clock runs during a conversion attempt except during the last three minutes of each half.
The use of small, rubberized "tees" for convert attempts (not the same as the kickoff tee, but rather a small plastic block; such tees come in heights of 1 or 2 in [25 or 51 mm]) varies depending on the level of play. Unlike in the lower ranks of play up to the high school level, the NFL (and most other professional leagues) has never allowed the use of "tees" for extra point kick attempts, having always required kickers to kick off the ground for such attempts (and for field goals); In 1948, the NCAA authorized the use of the small rubberized kicking tee for extra points and field goals, but banned them by 1989, requiring kicks from the ground, like in the NFL. The Canadian Football League, despite its status as a professional league, does allow for the use of such a tee for converts and field goals, but it is optional, as kickers can also kick off the ground if they so desire.
Prior to the 2015 season, the NFL used the 2-yard line (with the kick coming at the 10-yard line for a 20-yard attempt) for all conversion (P.A.T.) attempts (which was denoted on the field with a hashmark in the middle of the 2-yard line; although the line of scrimmage on the point after kick attempt was moved back in 2015, it remains to denote the two-point conversion's line of scrimmage). In Canadian football, the line of scrimmage was from the five-yard line (for a 12-yard attempt; unlike American football, no hashmark is used to denote the convert's line of scrimmage on the field in Canada).
In the NFL, the conversion was required after a touchdown scored during the regulation game (i.e., not overtime), because point differential is used for some tiebreakers in the standings. Rarely, this can result in such an attempt having to be made at the end of the game when it cannot change the outcome of the game; two of the best-known examples of this occurred after the winning touchdown by the Philadelphia Eagles in the December 19, 2010, game known as the Miracle at the New Meadowlands and after the controversial game-winning touchdown by the Seattle Seahawks on September 24, 2012.
If the game is in sudden death overtime, the extra-point attempt is omitted if the winning score is a touchdown. In American high school and college football, it is likewise omitted following a touchdown on the game's final play if a successful conversion attempt cannot change the outcome of the game.
There is, however, one exception in college football because the defense can also score two points on a return of a conversion try (and theoretically score a one-point safety) and the NCAA rules state that the conversion try must be run if any subsequent scoring on the play could impact the outcome of the game. Therefore, if a team scores a touchdown to take the lead by one or two points as time expires, they must still attempt the conversion, although most teams will simply opt to take a knee to prevent the risk of the defense scoring. For example, on October 24, 2009, Iowa scored as time expired to take a 15–13 lead over Michigan State. Making the conversion would have made no difference in Iowa winning the game, but Iowa still had to attempt it, so Ricky Stanzi simply knelt down, as a return by Michigan State would have tied the game and forced overtime.
In Canadian football, the scoring team is entitled to a conversion play after scoring with no time on the clock, but may choose to waive it if they feel it is not needed. Because head-to-head points scored is used as a tiebreaker in the standings between teams, they often choose to take it if it is against a division opponent with whom a tie in the standings is possible. As in U.S. college football, Canadian football allows defenses to score two points for the successful return of a convert attempt.
In the CFL, the line of scrimmage for a kick attempt moved back 20 yards to the 25-yard line (for a 32-yard attempt), while the line of scrimmage for a two-point attempt moved forward two yards to the three-yard line.
In the NFL, the line of scrimmage for a kick attempt moved back 13 yards to the 15-yard line (for a 23-yard attempt), effectively placing the ball the same distance from the goalposts as in the CFL. The line of scrimmage for a two-point attempt remained at the two-yard line. NFL defenses also became able to run back failed conversion attempts for a two-point score. On December 6, 2015, New Orleans Saints linebacker Stephone Anthony became the first player in NFL history to do so, after New Orleans blocked an extra-point kick by the Carolina Panthers. Some broadcasters did not immediately update their in-game graphics programming to account for the scoring of two points for the defensive return of a try, resulting in the score sometimes being erroneously displayed to audiences as a "safety" (which has the same scoring value).
As expected, the 2015 rule changes increased the frequency of two-point conversion attempts, from a rate of about five percent to about eight percent, much of that increase coming from the Pittsburgh Steelers alone.
Starting with the 2018 season, the NFL adopted the CFL rule allowing teams to waive "unnecessary" extra point attempts at the end of the game.
Special overtime rules
In most cases in gridiron football, one point may be scored following a touchdown—bringing the total value of the touchdown to seven points—by place kicking the ball through the uprights. Exceptions occur in overtime in some leagues. In American college football, if the game reaches the third or subsequent period of overtime, no further one-point kicks are allowed—only two-point conversions. In the CFL, one-point (kicking) converts are not available in overtime; all convert attempts must be for two-point (rushing or passing) converts. In the NFL, an overtime game automatically ends on a touchdown even on the first possession, so there is never a situation in overtime where a try would be possible.
In 1968, the AFL and NFL eliminated the extra-point kick for interleague preseason games, allowing only one-point scrimmage plays called "Pressure Points"; this was scrapped when both leagues began their regular seasons that year. The World Football League (which called their conversions "Action Points"), Alliance of American Football, and both the 2001 and 2020 incarnations of the XFL did the same in their short lives. The XFL later implemented a variable system that allowed increasing point values for increasing the distance to the end zone on the attempt for its 2001 playoffs, which is carrying over into the 2020 league; that system was later adopted by the Stars Football League and, in a reduced form, the Legends Football League. The CFL proposed to test the variable-distance scoring system during the 2015 preseason, but the proposal was rejected. In arena football, two points can also be scored by means of a drop-kicked field goal. Some youth football leagues turn the scoring upside-down to an extent, scoring one point for a running touchdown and two points for either a passing touchdown or field goal; six-man football follows a similar convention that rewards one point for a pass or run and two points for a kick.
- Kerkhoff, Blair (December 5, 2016). "Eric Berry's 'pick-two' is a phantom on stats sheet". The Kansas City Star. Retrieved December 9, 2016.
- Doug Lennox (24 August 2009). Now You Know Football. Dundurn. pp. 60–. ISBN 978-1-4597-1872-2.
- Doug Lennox (3 June 2017). Now You Know Canada: 150 Years of Fascinating Facts. Dundurn. pp. 66–. ISBN 978-1-4597-3944-4.
- "Justin Tucker Stats". Pro-Football-Reference.com. March 1, 2019. Retrieved March 1, 2019.
- "Tampa Bay Buccaneers at Green Bay Packers — September 25th, 2005". Pro-Football-Reference.com. 2005-09-25. Retrieved 2012-11-23.
- "Stephen Gostkowski's broken extra point streak proves costly". espn.go.com. 2016-01-25. Retrieved 2016-05-31.
- Forums.nfhs.org[permanent dead link]
- Litke, Jim (August 20, 1989). "They're Not All Kicking and Screaming Over the Absence of Tee". Los Angeles Times. Associate Press. Retrieved October 3, 2019.
The NFL allows the use of tees as high as 3 inches for kickoffs, but has never allowed them for field goals and PATs. The pro league, which began to declare its independence from the college game with a number of rules changes beginning in the mid-1930s, also has refused to widen the goal posts.
- "NCAA rules change will ban tees on FGs, PATs - The Tech". tech.mit.edu. Retrieved September 9, 2018.
- "No More Tee Party". CNN. September 4, 1989.
- "Frequently Asked Questions about Equipment". Retrieved 2019-10-03.
For place kicks (field goal and convert attempts) the kicking tee platform or block can be no higher than one inch in height as per Rule 5, Section 1, Article 3 of the CFL Rulebook. For kickoffs, the ball may be held or placed on a tee such that the lowest part of the ball is no higher than three inches off the ground; Kicking tees are not required to be used. Kickers may kick off the ground if they desire.
- Patra, Kevin (May 19, 2015). "NFL moves extra point to 15-yard line for 2015 season". National Football League. Retrieved May 21, 2015.
- Williams, Eric D. (May 19, 2015). "NFL changes PAT rule for 2015". ESPN.com. Retrieved May 20, 2015.
- Dabe, Christopher (December 6, 2015). "Stephone Anthony makes NFL history with return of blocked kick for 2-point conversion". nola.com. Retrieved December 7, 2015.
- Stuart, Chase (15 November 2016). "More NFL Teams Are Going For Two — Just As They Should Be". FiveThirtyEight. Retrieved 21 December 2016.
- "Steelers Are Getting Their 2 Points' Worth - The New York Times". Nytimes.com. Retrieved 2019-01-28.
- Wagner, Sean (2018-03-28). "NFL eliminates unnecessary PATs, two-point conversions after walk-off touchdowns". CBSSports.com. Retrieved 2019-01-28.
- Volk, Pete (September 1, 2016). "How does college football overtime work? A quick explainer, plus a video version". Sports Blog Nation. Retrieved October 11, 2016.
- "Section 8 — Tie Game". Canadian Football League Database. Retrieved November 9, 2017.
- Berardino, Mike (July 21, 2011). Tiger Woods, Steve Williams and the four-point field goal (Three Things). South Florida Sun-Sentinel. Retrieved July 25, 2011.
- "LFL Game Rules - Legends Football League". Lflus.com. Retrieved 2019-01-28.