John Henry Selman Sr.
November 16, 1839
|Died||April 6, 1896 (aged 56)|
El Paso, Texas, USA
|Cause of death||Killed by U.S. Marshal George Scarborough|
|Occupation||Lawman and outlaw|
John Selman (November 16, 1839 – April 6, 1896) was sometimes identified as an outlaw and sometimes a working lawman of the Old West. He is best known as the man who shot John Wesley Hardin in the Acme Saloon in El Paso, Texas, on August 19, 1895.
Early life, service with the Confederacy
John Henry Selman was born in Madison County, Arkansas. He was the son of Jeremiah Selman. The Selman family moved to Grayson County, Texas, in 1858. After his father's death on December 16, 1861, Selman joined the 22nd Texas Cavalry and served during the Civil War.
Life as a lawman
In 1877, Selman became a deputy inspector for hides, working under fellow inspector, ex-Shackleford County sheriff, John M. Larn. Selman and Larn fought against rustlers and vigilante justice in the lawless area of northwest Texas. The two were involved in several shootouts with bandits and outlaws during the period that followed. Then, on June 24, 1878, vigilantes shot Larn to death in an Albany, Texas, jail cell. Larn had been arrested after six hides, which did not belong to him, had been found behind his house. Even though Selman was out of town at the time, he was implicated in the theft, and found himself a wanted man, hunted by these same vigilantes, who were friends with several men who had previously been either arrested or killed by him.
Life as an outlaw
Selman went into hiding during this time, as he was also facing charges stemming from his desertion from the Confederate Army. Selman went to Mexico. However, the end of the war and the resulting dissolution of the Confederacy rendered any prior charges null, and Selman was free to return to the United States.
Selman's wife died in 1879, while giving birth to a stillborn child. The other four children were placed in the custody of his wife's niece. Selman by this time was living in Lincoln County, New Mexico. This was during the Lincoln County War. He organized a band, "Selman's Scouts" (known locally as 'The Rustlers'). The group was accused of numerous acts of rape and murder in the area. However, no charges were ever filed against him there.
Roscoe "Rustling Bob" Bryant was involved with John Selman's cattle rustling operation. Being a member of Selman’s Scouts, he was killed by his members near Seven Rivers, New Mexico in September, 1878. His body was found near Reese Gobly and James Irvin, presumably murdered by their fellows.
During that period, definitions of ownership varied, and there was widespread gossip and dramatic storytelling. In fact, during this particular period, Reconstruction era events such as the Lincoln County Wars, the HooDoo War, the Lee–Peacock Feud, the Sutton–Taylor feud, and the El Paso Salt War made definitions of criminality and intent very much a matter of who was doing the name-calling. Certainly, most of these events were continuances of Civil War hostilities, which went on for many years. Selman had both family and personal ties to participants in every one of these conflicts, making it far more likely that he was himself a participant. It would be almost impossible to cast either side of any of those conflicts as blameless, or without some criminal activity taking place in its name. Very often, it was common for Mexican bandits to come over the border and drive away cattle belonging to others, and yet because of the longstanding enmity between the factions involved, any such losses would almost invariably be blamed on the other side in the local disputes.
By 1880, the band had been driven from Lincoln County, and began operating in Jeff Davis County, Texas. Selman was captured shortly thereafter by Texas Ranger Joe McKidrict, and taken to Shackelford County for trial.
Escape and return to law enforcement
Selman escaped, and fled again to Chihuahua, Mexico, where he hid out until around 1888, when his name was cleared and all charges against him were dropped. While in Mexico, he sent for his children. The two youngest boys joined their father, but the two oldest remained in Brown County, Texas—never to see their father again. He then moved to El Paso, Texas, and on August 23, 1893, he married Romula Granadine. He began working as a constable, and spent time gambling. On April 5, 1894, Selman killed a former Texas Ranger named Bass Outlaw. Outlaw had recently been fired, due to his drinking and the threats he had made against a judge. Selman, encountering an inebriated Outlaw, had suggested that Outlaw needed to go home and sleep it off. When Outlaw declined to go home, however, the two instead walked to 'Tillie Howard's,' a local brothel favored by Outlaw. Outlaw created a disturbance at Howard's place, resulting in his fatal shooting of Texas Ranger Joe McKidrict. He also drew on Selman, who was shot and wounded twice in the thigh. Selman returned fire and killed Outlaw. Selman was not arrested for the shooting, which was ruled justified.
The shooting of John Wesley Hardin
El Paso policeman and Selman's son, John Jr., arrested the mistress of gunman John Wesley Hardin, Beluah M'rose (or "the widow M'Rose"), for "brandishing a gun in public." Hardin confronted the younger Selman over the arrest, and the two men had a verbal dispute. In some accounts, supported by members of Selman's family, Hardin actually pistol-whipped 'Young John' Selman, and threatened his life. After hearing of the argument, the elder Selman approached Hardin, on the afternoon of August 19, 1895. The two exchanged angry words. That night, Hardin went to the Acme Saloon, where he began playing dice. Shortly before midnight, Selman walked into the saloon to confront Hardin. Drawing his gun at the door, he walked up behind Hardin he fired, shooting Hardin in the back of the head, killing him instantly as he went for his gun. As Hardin lay on the floor, Selman fired three more shots into him. Selman was arrested, charged with murder, and stood trial. Selman testified that he had observed that Hardin had seen him enter in the mirror, and Hardin had gone for his gun. Selman swore he fired in self-defense, and a hung jury resulted in his release on bond, pending retrial.
On the night of April 5, 1896, Selman was killed in a shootout by US Marshal George Scarborough. The two men had been playing cards and gotten into an argument. It has been alleged that the argument that night was due to Scarborough having been good friends with Outlaw, who had been killed on that same date two years earlier by Selman. However, this is highly unlikely, as Scarborough and Selman had known one another for many years, and Outlaw was generally disliked by the other Rangers and was buried with no mourners present. Also, Selman had killed Hardin, who had in the past had serious disputes with Scarborough. Instead, it is far more likely that Scarborough's own testimony when he was tried for killing Selman was actually truthful. By this time, Young John had fallen in love with a Mexican girl, whose father, an ambassador, disapproved. He had the younger Selman jailed in Juarez. On this particular night, Selman, who had also been drinking with Scarborough, had prevailed upon him to help spring Young John from the jail across the border. Scarborough, usually a far more cautious type, had tried to decline, stirring Selman's wrath. According to Scarborough, both men exited to the alley where Selman drew on him first and Scarborough then killed Selman in self-defense, after which Scarborough returned alone. Scarborough was arrested for murder because it was found that Selman had no gun. Just before his trial, a thief was arrested and it was discovered he had Selman's gun. The thief stated that he had seen the shooting, and stolen Selman's gun before the crowd arrived. Scarborough was acquitted on murder charges and released.
Selman was originally buried in an unmarked grave in the Catholic section of El Paso's Concordia Cemetery. News reports of the day clearly state the burial was in the Catholic section. His grave marker, however, was placed in the middle of the Protestant Section of the cemetery.
- Note: Degraffenreid was a descendant of the original landgrave of North Carolina, a titled Swiss national in service to the English Crown.
- Kathy Weiser (December 2012). "Old West Legends: John Selman – Wicked Lawman and Vicious Outlaw". Legends of America. Retrieved 18 September 2014.
- Caldwell, C. R. (2010). Dead Right: The Lincoln County War. Lulu.com. p. 240. ISBN 9780615171524.
- "Old West Outlaw List – B". Legends of America. p. 3. Retrieved 25 July 2018.
- "Selman's Scouts (AKA: The Rustlers, The Wrestlers)". Angelfire.com. Retrieved 25 July 2018.
- "The John Kinney Gang (AKA: The Rio Grande Posse)". Angelfire.com. Retrieved 25 July 2018.
- "Gunfighter List". Legends of America. p. 2. Retrieved 25 July 2018.
- Bloom, Lansing Bartlett; Walter, Paul A. F. New Mexico historical review. 32. Albuquerque: University of New Mexico, Historical Society of New Mexico, School of American Research. p. 234.
- "John Selman Kills John Wesley Hardin". Texas State Historical Association. Retrieved September 18, 2014.
- "John Selman (lawman and outlaw)". Geni. Retrieved September 18, 2014.
- Note: The marker is in the protestant section: tier 7, lot 23, grave 11; Concordia's burial records reveal that at this location rests the remains of Virginia Lee Steinborn, a three year old girl that had died in a automobile accident in 1933.
- : John Henry Selman; at FrontierTimes.com
- Selman Guest Ranch, Harper County, Oklahoma; selmanguestranch.com
- John Selman, Gunfighter; Metz, Leon Claire; 1992.