Perpetual virginity of Mary
The perpetual virginity of Mary is the doctrine that Mary, the mother of Jesus Christ, was a virgin ante partum, in partu, et post partum—before, during and after the birth of Christ. It is one of the four Marian dogmas of the Catholic Church, and is held also by the Eastern Orthodox Churches in Eastern Christianity and by some Lutherans and Anglicans in Western Christianity.
There is no biblical basis for Mary's perpetual virginity. The belief arose at the end of the 2nd century in ascetic circles who believed that sex and marriage were symptoms of original sin, and was affirmed as orthodoxy during the 4th century debates between supporters of virginity on the one hand and Christian marriage on the other. Those debates centred on the question of whether scripture did or did not indicate that Mary had other children, for the Pauline epistles, the four canonical gospels, and the Acts of the Apostles, all mention the brothers (adelphoi) of Jesus; the scriptural evidence is not absolutely conclusive, but Thomas Aquinas said that although reason could not prove Mary's perpetual virginity it must be accepted because it was "fitting" that Jesus as the only-begotten son of God should also be the only-begotten son of Mary. The doctrine was established at the Council of Ephesus in 431 and the Lateran Council of 649 emphasised its threefold character before, during, and after the birth of Christ, but the lack of scriptural support led to it being largely abandoned by most Protestants following the Reformation.
The perpetual virginity of Mary is one of the four Marian dogmas of the Catholic Church, meaning that it is held to be a truth divinely revealed, the denial of which is heresy. (The other three are her role as Theotokos (meaning mother of God), her Immaculate Conception, and her bodily Assumption into heaven). It declares her virginity before, during and after the birth of Jesus, or in the definition formulated by Pope Martin I at the Lateran Council of 649:
The blessed ever-virginal and immaculate Mary conceived, without seed, by the Holy Spirit, and without loss of integrity brought him forth, and after his birth preserved her virginity inviolate.
Western Catholic and Eastern Orthodox churches both recognise Mary as Aeiparthenos, meaning "ever-virgin". Thomas Aquinas said that reason could not prove this, but that it must be accepted because it was "fitting", for as Jesus was the only-begotten son of God, so he should also be the only-begotten son of Mary, as a second and purely human conception would disrespect the sacred state of her holy womb. The 2nd century Gospel of James has a similar message, describing how the hand of the midwife who attempted to test the holy mother's integrity by inserting her finger into Mary's vagina burst into flames and withered.
The church teaches that her virginity before the birth is revealed by scripture and affirmed in the Apostles' Creed, which states that Jesus was "conceived of the Holy Spirit, born of the Virgin Mary"; Pope Martin's definition of her virginity at the moment of birth means that this caused no physical injury to her virginal seal, which is both symbol and part of her perfect virginity of body and soul; while the final aspect affirms that Mary continued as a virgin to the end of her Earthly life, having no physical relations with her husband nor bearing any further children. Symbolically, the perpetual virginity of Mary signifies a new creation and a fresh start in salvation history. It has been stated and argued repeatedly, most recently by the Second Vatican Council:
This union of the mother with the Son in the work of salvation is made manifest from the time of Christ's virginal conception … then also at the birth of Our Lord, who did not diminish his mother's virginal integrity but sanctified it... (Lumen Gentium, No.57)
Origins: 2nd century
The exact origin of the tradition of Mary's perpetual virginity is unknown; her ante-partum virginity is attested in the Gospel of Matthew and in the Gospel of Luke, but there is no biblical basis for her virginity during and after the birth. Mary's virginity, pre or post natal, seems to have attracted little theological attention prior to the end of the 2nd century, Ignatius of Antioch (c.35-108), for example, discussing it only to argue for the reality of Jesus's human birth against the docetic heretics who denied him any humanity. The idea of Mary's perpetual virginity first appears in a late 2nd century text called the Gospel of James (or Protoevangelium of James), "the ultimate source of almost all later Marian doctrine." In this story Mary remains a life-long virgin, Joseph is an old man who marries her without physical desire, and the brothers of Jesus are explained as Joseph's sons by an earlier marriage. The birth takes place in a cave near Bethlehem, and the new-born Jesus simply appears from a cloud and a blinding light and takes his mother's breast; two midwives are present outside the cave, one unnamed who believes, the other, Salome, who demands to touch the physical organs of the holy mother:
The midwife came out of the cave [in which the birth took place], and Salome met her. And she said to her: "Salome, Salome, I have I have a new sight to tell you; a virgin has brought forth, a thing which her nature does not allow." And Salome said: "As the Lord my God lives, unless I put (forward) my finger and test her condition, I will not believe that a virgin has brought forth." And Salome went in and made ready to test her condition. And she cried out saying: "I have tempted the living God..." (The Protoevangelium of Gospel of James, 19:3-20, quoted in Brown, 1978).
Salome's hand withers, but she prays to God for forgiveness and an angel appears and tells her to touch the Christ-child again, whereupon her hand is restored; the episode performs the same function as "doubting Thomas" in the Gospel of John.
James possibly derives from a sect called the Encratites, whose founder Tatian taught that sex and marriage were symptoms of original sin; its context was the growth of asceticism with its emphasis on celibacy, the monks seeing all sexual activity as tainted by sin. It was widely distributed and seems to have formed the basis of the stories of Mary in the Quran.
3rd-4th century establishment of orthodoxy
By the early 4th century the spread of monasticism had promoted celibacy as the ideal Christian state, and a moral hierarchy was established with marriage occupying the third rank below life-long virginity and widowhood. Around 380 Helvidius objected to the devaluation of marriage inherent in this view and argued that the two states, of virginity and marriage, were equal; but his contemporary Jerome, realising that this would lead to the Mother of God occupying a place in heaven lower than virgins and widows, defended her perpetual virginity in his immensely influential Against Helvidius, issued c.383.
Helvidius soon faded from the scene, but in the early 380s the monk Jovinian wrote that if Jesus did not undergo a normal human birth then he himself was not human, which was the teaching of the heresy known as Manichaeism. Jerome wrote against Jovinian but failed to mention this aspect of his teaching, and most commentators believe that he did not find it offensive. The only important Christian intellectual to defend Mary's virginity in partu was Ambrose, Archbishop of Milan, who was the chief target of the charge of Manicheism. For Ambrose, both the physical birth of Jesus by Mary and the baptismal birthing of Christians by the Church had to be totally virginal, even in partu, in order to cancel the stain of original sin, of which the pains of labor are the physical sign. It was due to Ambrose that virginitas in partu came to be included consistently in the thinking of subsequent theologians.
Jovinian's view was rejected at a Synod of Milan held under Ambrose's presidency in 390, after which Mary's perpetual virginity was established as the only orthodox view. The Council of Ephesus in 431 established a full general consensus on the subject, in 553 the Second Council of Constantinople gave her the title Aeiparthenons, meaning Perpetual Virgin, and at the Lateran Council of 649 Pope Martin I emphasised its threefold character, before, during, and after the birth of Christ.
The Protestant Reformation rejected the sanctity of virginity, and as a result marriage and parenthood were extolled, Mary and Joseph were seen as a normal married couple, and sexual abstinence was no longer regarded as a virtue. It also brought the idea of the Bible as the fundamental source of authority regarding God's word (sola scriptura), and the reformers noted that while holy scripture explicitly required belief in the virgin birth, it only permitted acceptance of perpetual virginity. But despite the lack of a clear biblical basis for the doctrine, it was supported by Martin Luther (who included it in the Smalcald Articles, a Lutheran confession of faith written in 1537) as well as by Huldrych Zwingli, John Calvin, and later John Wesley, the co-founder of Methodism. This was because these moderate reformers were under pressure from others more radical than themselves who held Jesus to have been no more than a prophet: Mary's perpetual virginity thus became a guarantee of the Incarnation, despite its shaky scriptural foundations. Notwithstanding this early acceptance by the reformers, modern Protestants, apart from some Lutherans and Anglo-Catholics, have largely rejected the perpetual virginity and it has rarely appeared explicitly in confessions or doctrinal statements.
Arguments and evidence
The New Testament explicitly affirms Mary's virginity only prior to the conception of Jesus. The problem facing theologians wishing to maintain her perpetual virginity is that the Pauline epistles, the four canonical gospels, and the Acts of the Apostles, all mention the brothers (adelphoi) of Jesus, with Mark and Matthew recording their names and Mark adding unnamed sisters.[Notes 1] The Gospel of James resolved the problem by turning the adelphoi into Joseph's children by an earlier marriage; this is still the view of the Orthodox Christian churches, but Jerome, believing that Joseph, like Mary, must have been a life-long virgin, said that they were the sons of a different Mary entirely, a kinswoman of the Virgin - a modern variation is that the second Mary, mentioned in John 19:25 as the wife of Clopas, was not a kinswoman of Mary's but that Clopas was Joseph's brother.
Further scriptural difficulties were added by Luke 2:6, which calls Jesus the "first-born" son of Mary, and Matthew 1:25, which adds that Joseph did not "know" (have sex with) his wife "until she had brought forth her firstborn son." Helvidius argued that first-born implies later births, and that the word "until" left open the way to sexual relations after the birth; Jerome, replying that even an only son will be a first-born, and that "until" did not have the meaning Helvidius construed for it, painted a repulsive word-portrait of Joseph having intercourse with a blood-stained and exhausted Mary immediately after she has given birth - the implication, in his view, of Helvidius's arguments. Opinions on the quality of Jerome's rebuttal range from the view that it was masterful and well-argued to thin, rhetorical and sometimes tasteless.
Two other 4th century Fathers, Gregory of Nyssa and Augustine, advanced a further argument by reading Luke 1:34 as a vow of perpetual virginity on Mary's part; the idea, first introduced in the Gospel of James, has little scholarly support today. Nevertheless, this argument, and those advanced by Jerome and Ambrose, were put forward by Pope John Paul II in his catechesis of August 28, 1996, as the four facts supporting the Church's ongoing faith in Mary's perpetual virginity:
...[T]here are no reasons for thinking that the will to remain a virgin, which Mary expressed at the moment of the Annunciation (cf. Luke 1:34) was then changed. Moreover, the immediate meaning of the words "Woman, behold your son!" "Behold your mother" (John 19:26), which Jesus addressed from the Cross to Mary and his favorite disciple, imply that Mary had no other children. ...[T]he word "firstborn" literally means "a child not preceded by another", and, in itself, makes no reference to the existence of other children. ...The phrase "brothers of Jesus" indicates "the children" of a Mary who was a disciple of Christ (cf. Matthew 27:56) and who is significantly described as "the other Mary" (Matthew 28:1). "They are close relations of Jesus, according to an Old Testament expression."
- Anglican Marian theology
- Assumption of Mary
- Immaculate Conception of Mary
- Lutheran Marian theology
- Roman Catholic Mariology
- Virgin birth of Jesus
- Mark 6:3 names James, Joses, Judas, Simon; Matthew 13:55 has Joseph for Joses, the latter being an abbreviated form of the former, and reverses the order of the last two; Mark 6:3 and Matthew 12:46 refer to unnamed sisters; Luke, John and Acts all mention brothers also. See Bauckham (2015) in bibliography, pages 6-9.
- Hesemann 2016, p. unpaginated.
- Bromiley 1995, p. 269.
- Miravalle 2006, p. 51.
- Losch 2008, p. 283.
- Boislcair 2007, p. 1465. sfn error: no target: CITEREFBoislcair2007 (help)
- Hunter 2008, p. 412.
- Bauckham 2015, p. 6-8.
- Brown 1978, p. 72.
- Dodds 2004, p. 94.
- Miravalle 2006, p. 61-62.
- Rahner 1975, p. 896.
- Polcar 2016, p. 186.
- Collinge 2012, p. 133.
- Rausch 2016, p. 173.
- Greene-McCreight 2005, p. 485.
- Miravalle 2006, p. 56.
- Fairbairn 2002, p. 100.
- Vuong 2019, p. 100-101.
- Miravalle 2006, p. 56-60.
- Fahlbusch 1999, p. 404.
- Miravalle 2006, p. 59.
- Brown 1978, p. 275.
- Boisclair 2007, p. 1465.
- Hunter 1993, p. 61.
- Lohse 1966, p. 200.
- Hunter 1993, p. 63.
- Hurtado 2005, p. 448.
- Burkett 2019, p. 242.
- Brown 1978, p. 276.
- Booton 2004, p. 55.
- Zervos 2019, p. unpaginated.
- Bromiley 1995, p. 271.
- Bell 2012, p. 110.
- Hunter 2008, p. 412-413.
- Hunter 1999, p. 423-424.
- Polcar 2016, p. 185.
- Hunter 1993, p. 56-57.
- Hunter 1993, p. 57.
- Hunter 1993, p. 59.
- Rosenberg 2018, p. unpaginated.
- Miller-McLemore 2002, p. 100-101.
- Miller-McLemore 2002, p. 100.
- Pelikan 1971, p. 339.
- Wright 1992, p. 237.
- Gill 2004, p. 1254.
- Campbell 1996, p. 150.
- MacCulloch 2016, p. 51-52,64.
- Campbell 1996, p. 47,150.
- Parmentier 1999, p. 550.
- Maunder 2019, p. 28.
- Nicklas 2011, p. 2100.
- Cross & Livingstone 2005, p. 238.
- Pelikan 2014, p. 160.
- Harrington 1991, p. 36 fn.25.
- Brown 1978, p. 278-279.
- Calkins 2008, p. 308-310.
- Bauckham, Richard (2015). Jude and the Relatives of Jesus in the Early Church. Bloomsbury. ISBN 9781474230476.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Bell, Richard (2012). The Origin of Islam in Its Christian Environment. Routledge. ISBN 9781136260674.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Boisclair, Regina A. (2007). "Virginity of Mary (Biblical Theology)". In Espín, Orlando O.; Nickoloff, James B. (eds.). An Introductory Dictionary of Theology and Religious Studies. Liturgical Press. ISBN 9780814658567.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Booton, Diane E. (2004). "Variations on a Limbourg Theme". In DuBruck, Edelgard E.; Gusick, Barbara I. (eds.). Fifteenth Century Studies. 29. Camden House. ISBN 9781571132963.
- Boring, M. Eugene (2006). Mark: A Commentary. Presbyterian Publishing. ISBN 9780664221072.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Boring, M. Eugene; Craddock, Fred B. (2009). The People's New Testament Commentary. Westminster John Knox. ISBN 9780664235925.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Bromiley, Geoffrey W. (1995). The International Standard Bible Encyclopedia. Eerdmans. ISBN 9780802837851.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Brown, Raymond Edward (1978). Mary in the New Testament. Paulist Press. ISBN 9780809121687.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Bruner, Frederick (2004). Matthew 1-12. Eerdmans. ISBN 9780802811189.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Burkett, Delbert (2019). An Introduction to the New Testament and the Origins of Christianity. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9781107172784.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Calkins, Arthur Burton, Msgr. (2008). "Our Lady's Perpetual Virginity". In Miravalle, Mark I. (ed.). Mariology: A Guide for Priests, Deacons, Seminarians, and Consecrated Persons. Seat of Wisdom Books. ISBN 9781579183554.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Campbell, Ted (1996). Christian Confessions: A Historical Introduction. Westminster John Knox Press. ISBN 9780664256500.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Collinge, William J. (2012). Historical Dictionary of Catholicism. Scarecrow Press. ISBN 9780810879799.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Cross, Frank Leslie; Livingstone, Elizabeth A. (2005). "Brethren of the Lord". The Oxford Dictionary of the Christian Church. Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780192802903.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Davids, Peter H. (2000). "Brothers of the Lord". In Freedman, David Noel; Myers, Allen C. (eds.). Eerdmans Dictionary of the Bible. Eerdmans. ISBN 9789053565032.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Dodds, Michael J. (2004). "The Teaching of Thomas Aquinas on the Mysteries of the Life of Christ". In Weinandy, Thomas Gerard; Keating, Daniel; Yocum, John (eds.). Aquinas on Doctrine:: A Critical Introduction. A&C Black. ISBN 9780567084118.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Fairbairn, Donald (2002). Eastern Orthodoxy Through Western Eyes. Westminster John Knox. ISBN 9780664224974.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Fahlbusch, Erwin (1999). "Mariology". In Fahlbusch, Erwin; Bromiley, Geoffrey William (eds.). The Encyclopedia of Christianity, Volume 3. Eerdmans. ISBN 9780802824158.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Fredriksen, Paula (2008). From Jesus to Christ: The Origins of the New Testament Images of Jesus. Yale University Press. ISBN 978-0300164107.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- George-Tvrtkovic, Rita (2018). Christians, Muslims, and Mary: A History. Paulist Press. ISBN 9781587686764.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Gill, Sean (2004). "Mary". In Hillerbrand, Hans J. (ed.). Encyclopedia of Protestantism. Routledge. ISBN 9781135960285.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Greene-McCreight, Kathryn (2005). "Mary". In Vanhoozer, Kevin J. (ed.). Dictionary for Theological Interpretation of the Bible. Baker Academic. ISBN 9780801026942.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Harrington, Daniel J. (1991). The Gospel of Matthew. Liturgical Press. ISBN 9780814658031.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Hesemann, Michael (2016). Mary of Nazareth: History, Archaeology, Legends. Ignatius Press. ISBN 9781681497372.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Hunt, Emily J. (2003). Christianity in the Second Century: The Case of Tatian. Routledge. ISBN 9781134409891.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Hunter, David G. (2008). "Marriage, early Christian". In Benedetto, Robert; Duke, James O. (eds.). The New Westminster Dictionary of Church History: The early, medieval, and Reformation eras. Westminster John Knox Press. ISBN 9780664224165.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Hunter, David G. (1999). "Helvidius". In Fitzgerald, Allan D. (ed.). Augustine Through the Ages. Eerdmans. ISBN 9780802838438.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Hunter, David G. (Spring 1993). "Helvidius, Jovinian, and the Virginity of Mary in Late Fourth-Century Rome". Journal of Early Christian Studies. Johns Hopkins University Press. 1 (1): 47–71. doi:10.1353/earl.0.0147. S2CID 170719507. Retrieved 2016-08-30.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Hurtado, Larry (2005). Lord Jesus Christ: Devotion to Jesus in Earliest Christianity. Eerdmans. ISBN 9780802831675.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Hurtado, Larry (2011). Mark. Baker Books. ISBN 9781441236586.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Isaak, Jon M. (2011). New Testament Theology: Extending the Table. Wipf and Stock Publishers. ISBN 9781556352935.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Lincoln, Andrew (2013). Born of a Virgin?. Eerdmans. ISBN 978-0802869258.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Lohse, Bernhard (1966). A Short History of Christian Doctrine. Fortress Press. ISBN 9781451404234.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Losch, Richard (2008). All the People in the Bible. Eerdmans. ISBN 9780802824547.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- MacCulloch, Diarmaid (2004). Reformation: Europe's House Divided 1490-1700. Penguin UK. ISBN 9780141926605.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- MacCulloch, Diarmaid (2016). All Things Made New: The Reformation and Its Legacy. Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780190616816.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Maunder, Chris (2019). "Mary and the Gospel Narratives". In Maunder, Chris (ed.). The Oxford Handbook of Mary. Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780198792550.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Migliore, Daniel L. (2002). "Woman of Faith". In Gaventa, Beverly Roberts; Rigby, Cynthia L. (eds.). Blessed One: Protestant Perspectives on Mary. Westminster John Knox Press. ISBN 9780664224387.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Miravalle, Mark I. (2006). Introduction to Mary: The Heart of Marian Doctrine and Devotion. Queenship Publishing. ISBN 9781882972067.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Miller-McLemore, Bonnie J. (2002). ""Pondering All These Things"". In Gaventa, Beverly Roberts; Rigby, Cynthia L. (eds.). Blessed One: Protestant Perspectives on Mary. Westminster John Knox Press. ISBN 9780664224387.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Nicklas, Tobias (2011). "Traditions About Jesus in Apocryphal Gospels". In Holmén, Tom; Porter, Stanley E. (eds.). Handbook for the Study of the Historical Jesus. BRILL. ISBN 978-9004163720.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Parmentier, Martin F.G. (1999). "Mary". In Van Der Toorn, Karel; Becking, Bob; Van der Horst, Pieter Willem (eds.). Dictionary of Deities and Demons in the Bible. Eerdmans.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Pelikan, Jaroslav (1971). The Christian Tradition: A History of the Development of Doctrine. 4: Reformation of Church and Dogma. University of Chicago Press. ISBN 9780226653778.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Pelikan, Jaroslav (2014). The Melody of Theology. Wipf and Stock. ISBN 9781625646453.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Polcar, Philip (2016). "Developments in the Doctrine of Mary's Perpetual Virginity in Antiquity (2nd-7th centuries AD)". In Curta, Florin; Holt, Andrew (eds.). Great Events in Religion: An Encyclopedia of Pivotal Events in Religious History: vol.1. ABC-CLIO. ISBN 9781610695664.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Pomplun, Trent (2008). "Mary". In Buckley, James J.; Bauerschmidt, Frederick C.; Pomplun, Trent (eds.). The Blackwell Companion to Catholicism. John Wiley & Sons. ISBN 9780470751336.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Rahner, Karl (1975). Encyclopedia of Theology: A Concise Sacramentum Mundi. A&C Black. ISBN 9780860120063.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Rausch, Thomas P. (2016). Systematic Theology: A Roman Catholic Approach. Liturgical Press. ISBN 9780814683453.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Reddish, Mitchell (2011). An Introduction to The Gospels. Abingdon Press. ISBN 9781426750083.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Rosenberg, Michael (2018). Signs of Virginity: Testing Virgins and Making Men in Late Antiquity. Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780190845919.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Salisbury, Joyce E. (2004). "Jerome, Saint". In Kleinhenz, Christopher (ed.). Medieval Italy: An Encyclopedia. Routledge. ISBN 9781135948801.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Schumaker, John F. (1992). Religion and Mental Health. Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780195361490.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Stowasser, Barbara Freyer (1996). Women in the Qur'an, Traditions, and Interpretation. Oxford University Press. ISBN 9780199761838.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Tilley, Maureen A. (1995). "One Woman's Body: Repression and Expression in the Passio Perpetuae". In Phan, Peter C. (ed.). Ethnicity, Nationality and Religious Experience. University Press of America. ISBN 9780819195241.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Vuong, Lily C. (2019). The Protevangelium of James. Wipf and Stock Publishers. ISBN 9781532656170.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Wiesner-Hanks, Merry (2005). Christianity and Sexuality in the Early Modern World: Regulating Desire, Reforming Practice. Routledge. ISBN 9781134761210.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Wheeler-Reed, David (2017). Regulating Sex in the Roman Empire: Ideology, the Bible, and the Early Christians. Yale University Press. ISBN 9780300231311.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Wright, David F. (1992). "Mary". In McKim, Donald K.; Wright, David F. (eds.). Encyclopedia of the Reformed Faith. Westminster John Knox Press. ISBN 9780664218829.CS1 maint: ref=harv (link)
- Zervos, George T. (2019). The Protevangelium of James: Greek Text, English Translation, Critical Introduction. 1. Bloomsbury Publishing. ISBN 9780567689757.