Plan for Establishing Uniformity in the Coinage, Weights, and Measures of the United States

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

The "Plan for Establishing Uniformity in the Coinage, Weights, and Measures of the United States" was a report submitted to the U.S. House of Representatives on July 13, 1790, by Secretary of State Thomas Jefferson.

At the First United States Congress, which met in 1789 when the decimal metric system had not yet been developed in France, the system of units to be used in the future USA was one point of discussion. Under the Constitution (article I, section 8), the Congress has the constitutional right to decide on a standard of weights and measures. On January 2, 1790, George Washington urged Congress to address the need for the uniform system of weights and measures, and on January 15, 1790, the House of Representatives requested Thomas Jefferson to draw up a plan.[1]

The decimal dollar had already been agreed upon in principle in 1785,[2] but would not be implemented until after passage of the Mint Act in 1792. After correspondence with William Waring[3] and others, Jefferson proposed two systems of units in mid-1790. The first was evolutionary, and was based on refinement of the definitions of the units of the existing English system, as well as simplification of their relationship to each other. The second system was revolutionary, and was based on units linked by powers of ten, very similar to the decimal metric system which would be proposed in France. The base units for length, mass, and volume in Jefferson's revolutionary system (named the foot, the ounce, and the bushel, respectively) were relatively close in size to their pre-existing counterparts and bore identical names, although the manner in which they were defined was very different.

Jefferson's proposal was the world's first scientifically based, fully integrated, decimal system of weights and measures.[1]

The seconds pendulum basis[edit]

In coordination with scientists in France, Jefferson selected the seconds pendulum at 45° latitude as the basic reference. For technical reasons, he proposed using a uniform rod as the pendulum rather than a traditional pendulum. The pendulum was estimated to be 39.14912 English inches long (which at that time was not yet defined to be exactly 25.4 mm, of course), or 1.5 times that for a vibrating rod (58.72368 inches).

Redefinition of the inch by the 45°N seconds pendulum or rod
base pendulum vibrating rod foot
original 39.14912 in 58.72368 in 304.801 mm
ideal pendulum 36 in = 3 ft = 1 yd 54 in 331.463 mm
ideal rod 40 in 60 in = 5 ft 298.317 mm
practical rod 39.16 in 58.75 in 304.664 mm
modern 39.13198 in 58.69796 in 304.8 mm

More traditional proposal[edit]

In the evolutionary approach, the foot was to be derived from these lengths by a simple integer factor, which would be either three (pendulum) or five (rod), i.e. lengthening it from the traditional value of about 324 mm by slightly over 1 inch to ca. 331 mm or shortening it by about a quarter of an inch to ca. 298 mm. For practical purposes he wanted the rod to be 58¾ (new) inches long, an increase of less than 0.045%.

For the mass units, the ounce as a base would equal the weight of one thousandth of a cubic foot of rain water at standard temperature.

Jeffersonian conservative proposal
Length
line 587 15 in standard rod
inch = 10 lines
foot = 12 inches
yard = 3 feet
ell = 3¾ feet
fathom = 6 feet
perch, pole = 5½ yards
furlong = 40 poles
mile = 8 furlongs
league = 3 miles
Area
rood = 40 square poles
acre = 4 roods
Volume
dry liquid
gill = ¼ pint
pint = ½ quart
quart = ½ pottle
pottle = ½ gallon
gallon = 270 cubic inches
peck = 2 gallons
bushel firkin = 4 pecks
strike kilderkin = 2 bushels or firkins
coomb barrel = 2 strikes or kilderkins
quarter hogshead = 2 coombs or barrels
tierce = 4/3 hogshead
pipe, butt, puncheon = 2 hogshead
ton = 2 pipes = 3 tierces = 4 quarters
Mass
grain = 1/24 pennyweight
pennyweight = 1/18 ounce
ounce = 1/1000 mH2O(1 cubic foot)
pound = 16 ounces

Although the rundlet is mentioned as an existing measure for liquids equivalent to a kilderkin, it was omitted from the list of redefinitions.

Decimal system based on the foot[edit]

Jefferson's proposed decimal system preceded the adoption in France of the decimal metric system, although both developed simultaneously. In France, the metre was to be defined as the ten-millionth part of an arc between the North Pole and the equator. Jefferson's system was based on the length of a rod oscillating seconds at 45 degrees latitude, with the foot defined as one fifth of the length of such a rod. Similar to the French system, Jefferson proposed a system of units linked directly by powers of ten. However, Jefferson's system did not make use of the concept of prefixes, which were of great importance in the French system. Instead, the names of old units were carried over into the new system for decimal multiples of the base units, giving them new values.

Asserting the value of such thorough reform to the existing system of weights and measures, the report stated:

But if it be thought that, either now, or at any future time, the citizens of the United States may be induced to undertake a thorough reformation of their whole system of measures, weights and coins, reducing every branch to the same decimal ratio already established in their coins, and thus bringing the calculation of the principal affairs of life within the arithmetic of every man who can multiply and divide plain numbers, greater changes will be necessary.

The following table lists the units of the Jeffersonian decimal system, and their relationship with one another. The values of these units are based on Jefferson's proposal of a foot that was equal in length to one-fifth of a second rod, one fourth of an inch shorter than the foot in use at the time, and approximately equal to 0.298461684 m.[4] For the mass units, the ounce as a base would equal the weight of a cubic inch of pure water at standard temperature.

Jeffersonian decimal proposal
Value relative to base unit SI equivalent USCS equivalent
Length
Point 0.001 0.29846 mm 11.75 mil (0.846 p)
Line 0.01 2.9846 mm 0.1175 in (0.705 )
Inch 0.1 2.9846 cm 1.175 in
Foot 1 2.9846 dm 11.75 in
Decad 10 2.9846 m 9.792 ft
Rood 100 2.9846 dam 97.92 ft (32.64 yd)
Furlong 1000 2.9846 hm 979.2 ft (326.4 yd)
Mile 10000 2.9846 km 1.85 mi
Area
Rood 1 = 1 rood² 8.9078 a 9588.424 ft²
Double Acre 10 0.89078 ha 2.2 acre
Volume
Metre 0.001 = 1 in³ 2.6587 cL 1.798 Tbsp
Demi-pint 0.01 2.6587 dL 8.99 fl oz
Pottle 0.1 2.6587 L 2.809 qt
Bushel 1 = 1 ft³ 2.6587 daL 7.023 gal
Quarter 10 2.6587 hL 70.23 gal (2.23 bbl)
Last, Double Ton 100 2.6587 m³ 702.3 gal (93.89 ft³)
Mass
Mite 0.0001 2.6587 mg 0.041 gr
Minim, Demi-Grain 0.001 2.6587 cg 0.41 gr
Carat 0.01 2.6587 dg 4.103 gr
Double Scruple 0.1 2.6587 g 41.03 gr
Ounce 1 mH2O(1 in³) 2.6587 dag 0.938 oz
Pound 10 2.6587 hg 9.38 oz
Stone 100 2.6587 kg 5.86 lb
Kental 1000 26.587 kg 58.6 lb
Hogshead 10000 265.87 kg 586.14 lb

The transcript of the original document gives the value of a kental as 16 stones at one point and 10 stones in another point. 10 was presumably the intended value, given the otherwise consistent decimalization.

Subsequent developments[edit]

Under the United States Constitution, Article 1 Section 8, Congress shall have power "To coin Money, regulate the Value thereof, and of foreign Coin, and fix the Standard of Weights and Measures". In his first annual message to Congress (what later came to be called "State of the Union Addresses") on January 8, 1790 (a few months before Jefferson's report to the House of Representatives), George Washington stated, "Uniformity in the currency, weights, and measures of the United States is an object of great importance, and will, I am pers­ed, be duly attended to."[5]

Washington repeated similar calls for action in his second[6] and third[7] annual messages (after Jefferson's report). Jefferson's decimal proposal had the support of Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, James Monroe, and George Washington. Robert Morris was a powerful opponent of the proposal.[1] In late 1791 the Senate appointed a committee to report on the subject and make recommendations. The committee reported in April 1792, unanimously endorsing Jefferson's decimal system. The Senate was slow to act on the matter and while they delayed events in France complicated the issue. Although French scientists working on a decimal system had originally supported using the seconds pendulum as a scientific basis, and Jefferson had deliberately matched his seconds pendulum proposal to the French one, based on a measurement at the latitude of Paris, the French decided to use the length of a meridian of the Earth instead of a seconds pendulum. This and other developments changed what had promised to be an internationally developed system into a strictly French project. Jefferson wrote, "The element of measure adopted by the National Assembly excludes, ipso facto, every nation on earth from a communion of measurement with them."[1]

The Senate continued to consider Jefferson's two proposals, along with a number of new proposals, for several years. In 1795 a bill titled "An Act directing certain experiments to be made to ascertain uniform standards of weights and measures for the United States" was passed by the House and was approved by committee in the Senate, but on the last day of the session the Senate said it would consider the bill during the next session. The bill was never taken up again. In 1795 the Northwest Indian War, which for years had prevented the surveying and sale of land in the Northwest Territory came to an end. A land rush of settlers, surveyors, squatters, and others rapidly pushed into the region and the federal government had a sudden and intense need to establish a method for surveying and selling land. On May 18, 1796 Congress passed "an Act for the sale of land of the United States in the territory northwest of the River Ohio, and above the mouth of the Kentucky River". This law defined a survey grid system of 6–mile–square townships divided into 1–mile–square sections, with the defining unit being the chain, specifically Gunter's chain. This was the first unit of measurement designated into law by Congress. This law and the way it defined the survey grid ended debate over Jefferson's decimal system.[1]

Origins[edit]

The proposal by William Waring from 30 January 1790[8] was similarly decimalized as Jefferson's more radical proposal, but introduces many new names for units and its base is the equatorial seconds pendulum, i.e. determined at 0° not 45°, called pend or federal ell. A federal gallon of 0.004 cubic pends, i.e. slightly less than 4 liters and thus similar in size to the English wine gallon, is suggested as a more traditional base for liquid measures; and 9 such gallons, since almost equal to a Winchester bushel, or, more systematically, 10 gallons would form the base for dry measures. Inspired by the Avoirdupois system defining 1 cubic foot of water to weigh 1000 ounces of which there are 16 to the pound, Waring suggests a federal pound of half a cubic hand of water, which would be just short of 0.5 kg.

Waring's proposal
Unit Definition Jeffersonian equivalence
"Lineal Measure"
Min 0.1 decu 13 line
Decu 0.1 hand 13 inch
Hand 0.1 pend 13 foot
Pend, Ell ca. 39 inches 13 decad
Caten 10 pends 13 rood
Muta 10 catens 13 furlong
Mile 10 mutas 13 mile
League 10 miles 3​13 miles
"Plane Measure"
Med 10 square decus 1 19 square inches
Foot 10 square hands 1 19 square feet
Floor or Square 10 square pends 1 19 square decads
Rood 10 square catens 1 19 roods
Acre 10 roods = 1 square muta 1 19 double-acre
Hide 10 acres 1​1 19 double-acres
"Solid Measure"
Bimin 10 cubic mins 1027 cubic lines
Trimin 10 bimins 3 1927 cubic lines
Bidecu 10 cubic decus 1027 metre
Tridecu 10 bidecus 1027 demi-pints
Bihand 10 cubic hands 1027 bushel
Trihand 10 bihands 1027 quarter
"Liquid Measure"
Met 0.1 pint 427 demi-pint
Pint 0.1 gallon 427 pottle
Gallon 4 cubic hands 427 bushel
Firkin 10 gallons 427 quarter
Vas or Hogshead 10 firkins 427 last
"Dry Measure"
Manu 0.1 pottle 1 13 or ​1 1327 demi-pint
Pottle 0.1 bushel 1 13 or ​1 1327 pottle
Bushel 9 or 10 gallons 1 13 or ​1 1327 bushel
Seem 10 bushels 1 13 or ​1 1327 quarter
Way 10 seems 1 13 or ​1 1327 last
"Weights"
Grain 0.1 dram 1 2327 carat
Dram 0.1 ounce 1 2327 double-scruple
Ounce 0.1 pound 1 2327 ounce
Pound mH2O(0.5 cubic hand) 1 2327 pound
Stone 10 pounds 1 2327 stone
Centon 10 stones 1 2327 kental
Mille 10 centons 1 2327 hogshead
Quinton 10 milles 18 1427 hogsheads

See also[edit]

Notes[edit]

  1. ^ a b c d e Linklater, Andro (2003). Measuring America: How the United States Was Shaped by the Greatest Land Sale in History. Plume. pp. 103–142. ISBN 978-0-452-28459-3. Retrieved 14 May 2012.
  2. ^ Journals of the Continental Congress, Wednesday, July 6, 1785
  3. ^ William Waring (1790-01-30): A Plan for Weights and Measures archived at Library of Congress
  4. ^ Hellman, C. Doris (Nov 1931). "Jefferson's Efforts towards the Decimalization of United States Weights and Measures". Isis. 16: 266–314. doi:10.1086/346612.
  5. ^ The American Presidency Project, George Washington: First Annual Message, accessed October 13, 2006
  6. ^ The American Presidency Project, George Washington: Second Annual Message, accessed October 13, 2006
  7. ^ The American Presidency Project, George Washington: Third Annual Message, accessed October 13, 2006
  8. ^ A Plan for the Regulation of Weights & Measures, respectfully proposed to the Legislature of the United States

References[edit]

External links[edit]