Primitive reflexes are reflex actions originating in the central nervous system that are exhibited by normal infants, but not neurologically intact adults, in response to particular stimuli. These reflexes are suppressed by the development of the frontal lobes as a child transitions normally into child development. These primitive reflexes are also called infantile, infant or newborn reflexes.
Older children and adults with atypical neurology (e.g., people with cerebral palsy) may retain these reflexes and primitive reflexes may reappear in adults. Reappearance may be attributed to certain neurological conditions including dementia (especially in a rare set of diseases called frontotemporal degenerations), traumatic lesions, and strokes. An individual with cerebral palsy and typical intelligence can learn to suppress these reflexes, but the reflex might resurface under certain conditions (i.e., during extreme startle reaction). Reflexes may also be limited to those areas affected by the atypical neurology, (i.e., individuals with cerebral palsy that only affects their legs retaining the Babinski reflex but having normal speech); for those individuals with hemiplegia, the reflex may be seen in the foot on the affected side only.
Primitive reflexes are primarily tested with suspected brain injury or some dementias such as Parkinson's disease for the purpose of assessing frontal lobe functioning. If they are not being suppressed properly they are called frontal release signs. Atypical primitive reflexes are also being researched as potential early warning signs of autistic spectrum disorders.
Primitive reflexes are mediated by extrapyramidal functions, many of which are already present at birth. They are lost as the pyramidal tracts gain functionality with progressive myelination. They may reappear in adults or children with loss of function of the pyramidal system due to a variety of reasons. However, with the advent of Amiel Tison method of neurological assessment, the importance of assessment of such reflexes in the pediatric population has come down.
Adaptive value of reflexes
Reflexes vary in utility. Some reflexes hold a survival value (e.g., the rooting reflex, which helps a breastfed infant find the mother's nipple). Babies display the rooting reflex only when they are hungry and touched by another person, not when they touch themselves. There are a few reflexes that likely assisted in the survival of babies during human evolutionary past (e.g., the Moro reflex). Other reflexes such as sucking and grabbing help establish gratifying interaction between parents and infants. They can encourage a parent to respond with love and affection, and to feed their child more competently. In addition, it helps parents to comfort their infant while allowing the baby to control distress and the amount of stimulation they receive.
The sucking reflex is common to all mammals and is present at birth. It is linked with the rooting reflex and breastfeeding. It causes the child to instinctively suck anything that touches the roof of their mouth and simulates the way a child naturally eats. There are two stages of the action:
- Expression: activated when the nipple is placed between a child's lips and touches their palate. They will instinctively press it between their tongue and palate to draw out the milk.
- Milking: The tongue moves from areola to nipple, coaxing milk from the mother to be swallowed by the child.
The rooting reflex is present at birth (age of appearance 28 weeks) and disappears around four months of age, as it gradually comes under voluntary control. The rooting reflex assists in the act of breastfeeding. A newborn infant will turn its head toward anything that strokes its cheek or mouth, searching for the object by moving its head in steadily decreasing arcs until the object is found. After becoming familiar to responding in this way (if breastfed, approximately three weeks after birth), the infant will move directly to the object without searching.
The Moro reflex is an important indicator for evaluating integration of the central nervous system, named after its discoverer, pediatrician Ernst Moro. Although this is sometimes referred to as the startle reaction, startle response, startle reflex or embrace reflex, most researchers see it as distinct from the startle reflex, and is believed to be the only unlearned fear in human newborns.
The Moro reflex is present at birth, peaks in the first month of life, and begins to integrate around 2 months of age. It is likely to occur if the infant's head suddenly shifts position, the temperature changes abruptly, or they are startled by a sudden noise. The legs and head extend while the arms jerk up and out with the palms up and thumbs flexed.[clarification needed] Shortly afterward the arms are brought together and the hands clench into fists, and the infant cries loudly.
The reflex normally integrates by three to four months of age, though it may last up to six months. Bilateral absence of the reflex may be linked to damage to the infant's central nervous system, while a unilateral absence could mean an injury due to birth trauma (e.g., a fractured clavicle or injury to the brachial plexus). Erb's palsy or some other form of paralysis is also sometimes present in such cases. In human evolutionary history, the Moro reflex may have helped infants cling to the mother while being carried around. If the infant lost its balance, the reflex caused the infant to embrace its mother and regain its hold on the mother's body.
The walking or stepping reflex is present at birth, though infants this young cannot support their own weight. When the soles of their feet touch a flat surface they will attempt to walk by placing one foot in front of the other. This reflex integrates around 5–6 months as infants start attempting to walk after this reflex disappears.
Asymmetrical tonic neck reflex (ATNR)
The asymmetrical tonic neck reflex, also known as 'fencing posture', is present at one month of age and integrates at around four months. When the child's head is turned to the side, the arm on that side will straighten and the opposite arm will bend (sometimes the motion will be very subtle or slight). If the infant is unable to move out of this position or the reflex continues to be triggered past six months of age, the child may have a disorder of the upper motor neurons. According to researchers,[who?] the tonic neck reflex is a precursor to the hand/eye coordination of the infant. It also prepares the infant for voluntary reaching.
Symmetrical tonic neck reflex
The symmetric tonic neck reflex normally appears and develops around 6–9 months of age and should integrate by around 12 months. When the child's head flexes forward, extending the back of the neck, the upper extremities will contract and the lower extremities will extend. Conversely, when the child's head is extended backward, contracting the back of the neck, the upper extremities will extend and the lower extremities will contract. This reflex is important to help a child push up onto their hands and knees but may inhibit actual forward creeping or crawling if it is not properly integrated. If this reflex is retained beyond 2–3 years, it may result, directly or indirectly, in a range of physical and neurological developmental delays.
Tonic labyrinthine reflex
The tonic labyrinthine reflex is a primitive reflex found in newborn humans. With this reflex, tilting the head back while lying on the back causes the back to stiffen and even arch backwards, the legs to straighten, stiffen, and push together, the toes to point, the arms to bend at the elbows and wrists, and the hands to become fisted or the fingers to curl. The presence of this reflex beyond the newborn stage is also referred to as abnormal extension pattern or extensor tone.
The presence of the TLR as well as other primitive reflexes such as the asymmetrical tonic neck reflex (ATNR) beyond the first six months of life may indicate that the child has developmental delays and/or neurological abnormalities. For example, in people with cerebral palsy, the reflexes may persist and even be more pronounced. As abnormal reflexes, both the tonic labyrinthine reflex and the asymmetrical tonic neck reflex can cause problems for the growing child. The TLR and ATNR both hinder functional activities such as rolling, bringing the hands together, or even bringing the hands to the mouth. Over time, both the TLR and ATNR can cause serious damage to the growing child's joints and bones, causing the head of the femur to partially slip out of the acetabulum (subluxation) or completely move out of the acetabulum (dislocation).
Palmar grasp reflex
The palmar grasp reflex appears at birth and persists until five or six months of age. When an object is placed in the infant's hand and strokes their palm, the fingers will close and they will grasp it with a palmar grasp. To best observe this reflex, on a bed where the child could safely fall onto a pillow, offer the infant two opposing little fingers (as index fingers are typically too large for the infant to grasp), and gradually lift. The grasp of it may be able to support the child's weight; they may also release their grip suddenly and without warning. The reverse motion can be induced by stroking the back or side of the hand.
A plantar reflex is a normal reflex that involves plantar flexion of the foot, which moves toes away from the shin and curls them down. An abnormal plantar reflex (Babinski sign) occurs when upper motor neuron control over the flexion reflex circuit is interrupted. This results in a dorsiflexion of the foot (foot angles towards the shin, big toe curls up). This also occurs in babies under c. 1 year, because of low myelination of the corticospinal tracts. As these tracts develop to adult form, the flexion-reflex circuit is inhibited by the descending corticospinal inputs, and the normal plantar reflex develops. The Babinski reflex is a sign of neurological abnormality (e.g., upper motor neuron lesion) in adults.
The Galant reflex, also known as Galant's infantile reflex, is present at birth and fades between the ages of four to six months. When the skin along the side of an infant's back is stroked, the infant will swing towards the side that was stroked. If the reflex persists past six months of age, it is a sign of pathology. The reflex is named after the Russian neurologist Johann Susman Galant.
The swimming reflex involves placing an infant face down in a pool of water. The infant will begin to paddle and kick in a swimming motion. The reflex disappears between 4–6 months. Despite the infant displaying a normal response by paddling and kicking, placing them in water can be a very risky procedure. Infants can swallow a large amount of water while performing this task, therefore caregivers should proceed with caution. It is advisable to postpone swimming lessons for infants until they are at least three months old because infants submerged in water can die from water intoxication.
The Babkin reflex occurs in newborn babies, and describes varying responses to the application of pressure to both palms. Infants may display head flexion, head rotation, opening of the mouth, or a combination of these responses. Smaller, premature infants are more susceptible to the reflex, with an observed occurrence in a child of 26 weeks gestation. It is named after the Russian physiologist, Boris Babkin.
This reflex occurs in slightly older infants (starts between 6 and 7 months and become fully mature by 1 year of age) when the child is held upright and the baby's body is rotated quickly to face forward (as in falling). The baby will extend their arms forward as if to break a fall, even though this reflex appears long before the baby walks.
Reflexes that are not suppressed in infancy are referred to as unintegrated or persistent reflexes. When they persist, they are related to academic struggles. For example, children with learning difficulties have been found to exhibit persistent primitive reflexes. In addition, a persistent ATNR has been found to be associated with lower reading and spelling scores, and children with reading problems tend to display the tonic labyrinthine reflex more than children without reading problems. Lastly, a relationship has been found between ADHD symptoms and ATNR persistence and another between ADHD diagnosis and Moro and Galant reflex persistence.
Other primitive reflexes tested in adults
As mentioned in the introduction, when primitive reflexes are not being suppressed properly they are generally referred to as frontal release signs (although this may be a misnomer). In addition to the reflexes previously mentioned, they include the palmomental reflex, snout reflex, glabellar reflex or "tap" reflex.
Primitive reflexes in high-risk newborns
The term high-risk newborns refers to neonates with a significant chance of mortality or morbidity, especially within the first month of being born. High-risk newborns will often show abnormal responses of primitive reflexes, or lack a response entirely. Performance of primitive reflexes in high-risk newborns will often vary in response depending on the reflex (e.g., normal Moro reflex may be present, while the walking reflex is absent or abnormal). Normal performance of primitive reflexes in newborns can be linked to a greater likelihood of having higher Apgar scores, higher birth weight, shorter hospitalization time after birth, and a better overall mental state.
A 2011 cross-sectional study assessing primitive reflexes in 67 high-risk newborns, used a sample method to evaluate responses of the sucking, Babinski and Moro reflexes. The results of the study showed that the sucking reflex was performed normally most often (63.5%), followed by the Babinski reflex (58.7%), and the Moro reflex (42.9%). The study concluded that high-risk newborns presented more periodic abnormal and absent responses of primitive reflexes, and that each reflex varied in response.
However, with the advent of simple and effective methods like the Amiel Tison method of neurological assessment, as predictor of neurological sequelae in high-risk neonates and infants, the importance of assessment of primitive reflexes is decreasing.
- "Primitive & Postural Reflexes" (php). Retrieved 2008-10-23.
- Rauch, Daniel (2006-10-05). "Infantile reflexes on MedLinePlus". MedlinePlus. Retrieved 2007-10-11.
- Schott, JM; Rossor, MN (2003). "The grasp and other primitive reflexes". J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry. 74 (5): 558–60. doi:10.1136/jnnp.74.5.558. PMC 1738455. PMID 12700289.
- Teitelbaum, O.; Benton, T.; Shah, P. K.; Prince, A.; Kelly, J. L.; Teitelbaum, P. (2004). "Eshkol-Wachman movement notation in diagnosis: the early detection of Asperger's syndrome". Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 101 (32): 11909–14. Bibcode:2004PNAS..10111909T. doi:10.1073/pnas.0403919101. PMC 511073. PMID 15282371.
- Amiel-Tison C, Grenier A. Neurological Assessment during first year of life. New York. Oxford University Press, 1986; 46-94.
- Paro-Panjan, D; Neubauer, D; Kodric, J; Bratanic, B (Jan 2005). "Amiel-Tison Neurological Assessment at term age: clinical application, correlation with other methods, and outcome at 12 to 15 months". Developmental Medicine and Child Neurology. 47 (1): 19–26. doi:10.1111/j.1469-8749.2005.tb01035.x. PMID 15686285. S2CID 20486547.
- Leroux, BG; N'guyen The Tich, S; Branger, B; Gascoin, G; Rouger, V; Berlie, I; Montcho, Y; Ancel, PY; Rozé, JC; Flamant, C (22 February 2013). "Neurological assessment of preterm infants for predicting neuromotor status at 2 years: results from the LIFT cohort". BMJ Open. 3 (2): e002431. doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2012-002431. PMC 3586154. PMID 23435797.
- Berk, Laura E.. Child Development. 8th. USA: Pearson, 2009.
- Odent M. The early expression of the rooting reflex. Proceedings of the 5th International Congress of Psychosomatic Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Rome 1977. London: Academic Press, 1977: 1117-19.
- Fletcher, Mary Ann (1998). Physical Diagnosis in Neonatology. Philadelphia: Lippincott-Raven. p. 472. ISBN 978-0397513864. Retrieved 7 February 2013.
- The American Academy of Pediatrics (1998). Shelov, Stephen P.; Hannemann, Robert E. (eds.). Caring for Your Baby and Young Child: Birth to Age 5. Illustrations by Wendy Wray and Alex Gray (Revised ed.). New York, NY: Bantam. ISBN 978-0-553-37962-4. LCCN 90-47015.
- Rauch, Daniel (2006-10-05). "MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia: Moro Reflex". Retrieved 2007-10-11.
- "Keeping Kids Healthy: Newborn Reflexes". 2001-10-14. Archived from the original on 2001-11-22. Retrieved 2007-10-11.
- Siegler, R.; Deloache, J.; Eisenberg, N. (2006). How Children Develop. New York: Worth Publishers. p. 188. ISBN 978-0-7167-9527-8.
- O'Dell, Nancy. "The Symmetric Tonic Neck Reflex (STNR)" (PDF). NDC Brain.com. Pediatric Neuropsychology Diagnostic and Treatment Center. Retrieved 9 March 2017.
- "Symmetrical Tonic Neck Reflex". Vision Therapy at Home. Retrieved 9 March 2017.
- Shelov, Steven (2009). Caring for your baby and young child. American Academy Of Pediatrics.
- Khwaja, JIACM 2005; 6(3): 193-7: "Plantar Reflex"
- "Babinski's reflex". MedlinePlus. Retrieved 11 January 2010.
- "The Galant Reflex".
- Pedroso, Fleming S.; Rotta, Newra T. (2004). "Babkin Reflex and Other Motor Responses to Appendicular Compression Stimulus of the Newborn". Journal of Child Neurology. 19 (8): 592–596. doi:10.1177/088307380401900805. PMID 15605468. S2CID 22525789.
- Parmelee, Arthur H., Jr. (May 5, 1963). "The Hand-Mouth Reflex of Babkin in Premature Infants". Pediatrics. 31 (5): 734–740. PMID 13941546.
- Grzywniak, C. (2016). "Role of early-childhood reflexes in the psychomotor development of a child, and in learning". Acta Neuropsychologica. 14 (2): 113–129. doi:10.5604/17307503.1213000 (inactive 2021-01-13).CS1 maint: DOI inactive as of January 2021 (link)
- McPhillips, M. (2007). "Primary reflex persistence in children with reading difficulties (dyslexia): A cross-sectional study". Neuropsychologia. 45 (4): 748–54. doi:10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2006.08.005. PMID 17030045. S2CID 79446.
- Ramirez Gonzalez, S.; Ciuffreda, K.J.; Castillo Hernandez, L.; Bernal Escalante, J. (2008). "The correlation between primitive reflexes and saccadic eye movements in 5th grade children with teacher-reported reading problems". Optometry & Vision Development. 39 (3): 140–145.
- Konicarova, J.; Bob, P. (2013). "Asymmetric tonic neck reflex and symptoms of attention deficit and hyperactivity disorder in children". International Journal of Neuroscience. 123 (11): 766–9. doi:10.3109/00207454.2013.801471. PMID 23659315. S2CID 16007573.
- Konicarova, J.; Bob, P. (2012). "Retained primitive reflexes and ADHD in children". Activitas Nervosa Superior. 54 (3–4): 135–138. doi:10.1007/BF03379591. S2CID 145739721.
- Sohn, M.; Ahn, L.; Lee, S. (2011). "Assessment of Primitive Reflexes in Newborns". Journal of Clinical Medicine Research. 3 (6): 285–290. doi:10.4021/jocmr706w. PMC 3279472. PMID 22393339.
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Primitive reflexes.|
- "PediNeuroLogic Exam - Movies of infant reflex testing". Retrieved 2007-10-11.
- "Medri Vodcast: Neonatology - Movies of the neurological examination of the newborn infant". Retrieved 2008-05-02.[permanent dead link]